Investigation Report
Generated on Jun 17, 2026
CardsGalleryCollection
https://www.ebay.com/itm/204504196930Â Why we think so?Â
🔎 This eBay listing is for a Pokémon S-Chinese Dawn’s Piplup Holo card, priced at $23.99, from seller CardsGalleryCollection in China. The seller profile looks strong on paper: 99.7% feedback, about 53K items sold, and 5.5K followers. That said, the listing has a few caution points: no returns, a very high sold count on a collectible card listing, and mixed listing data such as Chinese-language card details with “Country of Origin: Japan.”
Overall, this does not look like a clear scam, but it does merit caution. The price is a bit above the recent ungraded market range of about $18–$21, so you are paying a small premium. If you buy, inspect photos closely, save the listing, and be ready to use eBay’s Money Back Guarantee if the card arrives damaged or unlike the photos. ✅
Risk Insights
Strong seller footprint
- 99.7% feedback is a good sign.
- 53K items sold suggests an established store.
- This lowers the odds of a throwaway scam account.
Watch the listing details
- No returns accepted.
- Country-of-origin and language details do not fully align.
- That is worth a closer photo check before buying.
Price is not a bargain trap
- $23.99 is slightly above recent market levels.
- The card is not so cheap that it screams fake.
- You are paying retail, not a clearance price.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- No returns are accepted, which makes problems harder to resolve if the card is wrong, damaged, or counterfeit.
- The listing metadata is not fully consistent, especially the mix of Chinese-language product details and Japan as country of origin.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller reputation
Score: 84
Seller reputation
"Strong overall reputation, though recent feedback would still be better than lifetime totals alone."
Reason: The seller’s 99.7% feedback and large sales volume are solid signals of an established eBay store.
Listing consistency
Score: 58
Listing consistency
"This is not proof of fraud, just a reason to inspect the photos and description carefully."
Reason: The card details are mostly coherent, but the country-of-origin field and product language do not line up perfectly.
Price reasonableness
Score: 74
Price reasonableness
"The card does not look aggressively marked up for a rare variant."
Reason: At $23.99, the listing sits a little above recent ungraded market prices, but not wildly outside normal retail range.
Return protection
Score: 45
Return protection
"eBay’s Money Back Guarantee still helps if the item is not as described."
Reason: The seller does not accept returns, which reduces buyer flexibility if the item arrives with issues.
Counterfeit risk signals
Score: 68
Counterfeit risk signals
"The evidence set includes general counterfeit risk in the category, not a specific accusation against this seller."
Reason: No direct evidence shows this seller is selling counterfeits, but collectible cards from overseas sellers deserve a closer look.
Commercial scale
Score: 82
Commercial scale
"High activity can be good, but it does not by itself guarantee authenticity."
Reason: About 53K items sold and 5.5K followers point to an active, established business presence.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Check the item photos at full resolution and compare the holo pattern, font, and card number against known authentic copies.
-
2
Review the seller’s most recent feedback, not just the lifetime percentage, and look for mentions of fake, counterfeit, or not as described.
-
3
If you buy it, pay only through eBay so you keep Money Back Guarantee protection.
-
4
Treat the card as a cautious buy rather than a confidence purchase, especially because the seller does not accept returns.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
eBay product listing
⤷ Listing shows a PokĂ©mon S-Chinese Dawn’s Piplup Holo card priced at $23.99, with no returns accepted and seller location in China.
-
eBay seller profile
⤷ Seller CardsGalleryCollection shows 99.7% feedback, about 53K items sold, and 5.5K followers.
-
Market context for this card
⤷ Recent market data places ungraded copies of this card around the high teens to low twenties in USD.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
đź“ž Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.