Cottage In Valencia De Alcántara · 6 Bedrooms · 11 Beds · 3 Baths (Airbnb) Investigation & Evidence Report
Generated on Jan 23, 2026
Cottage in Valencia de Alcántara · 6 bedrooms · 11 beds · 3 baths
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1512432268740207856Why we think so?
This Airbnb listing is for a large cottage near Valencia de Alcántara, Spain, accommodating up to 18 people with 6 bedrooms and 11 beds. Numerous, authentic-looking photos (over 60) show the full interior, exterior, pool, multiple kitchens, and bedrooms, indicating a real, substantial property. However, the listing has several risk signals: the host 'Emilio' only started in 2025, has no listed guest reviews, is not a Superhost, and the property itself is not location-verified by Airbnb. Safety amenities like smoke and carbon monoxide alarms are notably missing. There’s also a strict and non-refundable cancellation policy. While the listing appears physically genuine, the lack of host reputation and guest feedback creates uncertainty for prospective guests. Booking through Airbnb’s official channels offers payment protection, but caution is advised due to the absence of supporting guest experiences.🛡️
Risk Insights
No Guest Reviews
- This listing has not received any ratings or feedback.
- No way to verify guest experiences or quality.
New Host, Limited Track Record
- Host 'Emilio' began hosting in 2025.
- Not a Superhost and no proven history yet.
No Safety Alarms Reported
- No smoke or carbon monoxide alarms documented.
- Consider bringing your own detector.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- New host with no reviews or ratings makes it hard to verify reliability.
- No evidence of location verification or guest feedback is present.
- Important safety devices (smoke and CO alarms) are not reported.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Authenticity of property imagery
Score: 95
Authenticity of property imagery
""
Reason: Extensive and diverse set of 60+ high-quality photos across different rooms and outside views supports the property’s physical existence.
Host verification and history
Score: 35
Host verification and history
"No host reputation information, ratings, or previous guest interactions."
Reason: Host is Airbnb-verified but only started hosting in 2025, and is not a Superhost. There is no visible hosting history or indication of prior rentals.
Guest reviews and ratings
Score: 0
Guest reviews and ratings
"No third-party verification of stay quality or host reliability."
Reason: There are no public reviews, ratings, or guest feedback, which is very unusual for a property of this size and investment.
Location verification
Score: 40
Location verification
""
Reason: Airbnb does not show location verification for this listing, so physical location hasn't been user-verified through Airbnb's systems.
Technical platform protections
Score: 80
Technical platform protections
""
Reason: Booking and payments are managed through Airbnb, which offers secure payment and customer protections against fraud.
Content and property details accuracy
Score: 85
Content and property details accuracy
""
Reason: Listing provides thorough amenity information, house rules, and numerous descriptive sections. Description seems internally consistent and well-structured.
Legal and regulatory compliance
Score: 80
Legal and regulatory compliance
""
Reason: The property claims a Spanish national registry exemption, which may be valid for some rural properties. No evidence presented contradicts compliance.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Message the host through Airbnb and ask any specific questions about your stay.
-
2
Do not send payment outside Airbnb’s payment system under any circumstances.
-
3
Ask the host about the lack of reviews and their experience hosting.
-
4
Consider accommodations with more established reviews and Superhost status if peace of mind is a priority.
-
5
If you book, carefully review the strict non-refundable cancellation policy.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Listing details on Airbnb: 'Cottage in Valencia de Alcántara'
⤷ Includes all imagery, property and host information, and amenity list but lacks reviews and verified location.