Home In Hvar · 7 Bedrooms · 12 Beds · 7.5 Baths (Airbnb) Investigation & Evidence Report
Generated on Jan 15, 2026
Home in Hvar · 7 bedrooms · 12 beds · 7.5 baths
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1169627237864869789Why we think so?
This listing for a villa in Hvar, Croatia, presents as a large, well-equipped property with plentiful amenities and extensive, high-quality imagery. However, a few important red flags stand out: the host is new (started in 2024), there are just two guest reviews, and basic safety equipment (smoke and carbon monoxide alarms) is missing. While the place itself looks legitimate, these gaps mean you should approach carefully and not book off-platform. Proceed only if you’re comfortable with the limited guest history and lack of safety devices. 🛡️
Risk Insights
Host is New and Unproven
- Host account started in 2024.
- No Superhost badge.
- No host review history.
Excellent Photo Documentation
- 213+ authentic, varied images.
- Covers bedrooms, pool, kitchen, and more.
Missing Safety Alarms
- No smoke alarm or carbon monoxide detector reported.
- Airbnb suggests bringing your own detector.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Very limited host history and no Superhost status.
- Low number of guest reviews (just two).
- Lack of basic safety amenities (smoke and CO alarms).
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Host Identity and Track Record
Score: 35
Host Identity and Track Record
"A new host is not necessarily unsafe, but increases background risk—especially with such a large property."
Reason: The host, Albert, is new as of 2024, has no previous rating average, and provides little personal or professional context.
Listing Imagery and Description Authenticity
Score: 90
Listing Imagery and Description Authenticity
"Authentic photo documentation helps reduce the risk of misrepresentation."
Reason: The listing features over 200 detailed images of rooms and facilities, showing specifics such as the layout and amenities.
Guest Reviews and Reputation
Score: 40
Guest Reviews and Reputation
"A property of this scale usually attracts more feedback—lack of reviews may result from newness, but weakens trust."
Reason: Only two guest reviews are visible, making it difficult to assess guest satisfaction and reliability long-term.
Amenities and Safety
Score: 45
Amenities and Safety
"This is a key safety shortcoming, especially in a large villa."
Reason: Both smoke and carbon monoxide detectors are missing or not reported.
Booking Channel Authenticity
Score: 85
Booking Channel Authenticity
"Paying within the Airbnb system grants buyer protection and gives confidence against payment fraud."
Reason: Booking is handled through Airbnb with no off-platform payment requests.
Legal Policies and Business Standing
Score: 60
Legal Policies and Business Standing
"Be wary with strict, non-refundable bookings if there are few reviews."
Reason: The policies and cancellation terms are standard, though the strict non-refundable policy is notable.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Contact the host using Airbnb's messaging system to confirm details and see whether prompt, clear responses are provided.
-
2
Ask specifically about the presence (or absence) of smoke and carbon monoxide detectors.
-
3
Review cancellation policies carefully; this listing is marked non-refundable.
-
4
Do not use off-platform payment methods; always book and pay through Airbnb.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Full Airbnb Listing Data
⤷ All findings based on the full public Airbnb listing, including host info, amenities, policies, and photo set.