Ebay Investigation Report
Report generated: Jan 5, 2026
Pokemon Phantasmal Flames Booster Box Sealed (eBay Seller: will1_39)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/406505754566Why we think so?
This listing offered a sealed "Pokemon Phantasmal Flames Booster Box" from the seller will1_39 on eBay and is now sold out. The seller's feedback score is 92.9, which is relatively low compared to many established eBay sellers. No direct reports accuse will1_39 of scams, fake reviews, or counterfeit products in major forums, and price for the booster box was $195—lower than the typical recent market values ($241–$305), although not significantly out of line. The listing showed 12 units sold and was marked as new/factory sealed, shipping from South Carolina. However, there are a few caution flags: Will1_39 does not accept returns (except if the item arrives not as described, covered by eBay's Money Back Guarantee), and little additional feedback data is available. While no public complaints target the seller, the lack of robust positive history or detailed storefront information warrants caution. If you intend to buy from will1_39 in the future, carefully review newer listings, check that product images look authentic, and avoid unusually low prices. 🕵️♂️
Risk Insights
Low feedback score is a concern
- Seller feedback is only 92.9, much lower than reputable eBay norms.
- This may indicate previous disputes or dissatisfied buyers.
No evidence of scams or fakes
- Searches found no scam or counterfeit warnings linked to this seller.
- No direct buyer complaints on eBay forums.
No-returns policy increases buyer risk
- Seller only accepts returns if protected by eBay’s policies.
- You may have trouble with after-sale support if an issue arises.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Low feedback score for seller.
- Seller's no-returns policy increases buyer risk.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller Feedback & Trust Score
Score: 45
Seller Feedback & Trust Score
"A score below 95% often signals repeated issues or dissatisfied buyers."
Reason: The feedback score (92.9) is substantially below the typical 98%+ for trustworthy eBay sellers, which raises reliability concerns.
Review Authenticity & Complaint Evidence
Score: 70
Review Authenticity & Complaint Evidence
"Caution is still recommended due to limited positive feedback volume."
Reason: No direct public complaints, scam warnings, or counterfeit accusations have surfaced regarding this seller across trusted forums or search.
Product Listing Accuracy and Consistency
Score: 75
Product Listing Accuracy and Consistency
"Condition, photos, and details match norms for this trading card product."
Reason: Product appears consistent with established listings (correct title/description, images, and market pricing).
Fulfillment Patterns & Inventory History
Score: 50
Fulfillment Patterns & Inventory History
"Lack of store branding or ongoing listing activity indicates weak business legitimacy."
Reason: Seller has sold 12 of this item, but broader inventory and fulfillment information is limited. No robust history to boost confidence.
Returns Policy & Buyer Protection
Score: 40
Returns Policy & Buyer Protection
"A seller-initiated return policy shows more consumer confidence than relying on eBay’s guarantees alone."
Reason: Seller does not accept returns except via the eBay Money Back Guarantee, which limits buyer protection.
Legal and Authenticity Signals
Score: 80
Legal and Authenticity Signals
"Product details and eBay coverage align with normal compliance."
Reason: No legal actions or scam/counterfeit reports are linked to seller or listing.
Your Next Steps
-
1
If you are considering future purchases from this seller, look for a higher feedback score and read individual buyer comments closely.
-
2
Inspect the item photos in detail for stock images versus real pictures.
-
3
Only use eBay checkout and avoid off-site payment requests.
-
4
If you receive an item that's not as described, use the eBay Money Back Guarantee promptly.
Evidence & Citations
-
eBay seller profile and feedback
Displays feedback score and selling activity.
-
eBay community forum threads regarding scams and review authenticity
General advice and eBay review issues described, but no mention of will1_39.
-
Pokemon Phantasmal Flames Booster Box Price Chart
Shows recent prices for the same product on resale markets.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
How WebVetted investigates fraud »Understand our methodology, founder background, and why people trust us.
Scam Encyclopedia »Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.