Ebay Investigation Report
Report generated: Dec 14, 2025
Marvel Mattel Spider Man Squishy Soft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 8” – grizzly_goods (eBay) Listing Review
https://www.ebay.com/itm/406044151166Why we think so?
This eBay listing is for a "Marvel Mattel Spider Man Squishy Soft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 8”" sold by the seller grizzly_goods. The seller has a feedback score of 100 and has sold 113 units of this item, with 4 reviews shown. No credible complaints or scam reports are associated with grizzly_goods on eBay or from web search results. The listing price of $3 (plus ~$4.91 shipping) is notably below typical retail rates for similar new Marvel/Mattel plush items, which usually range $10–$20. The product is described as new, with official branding and origin marked as China. Seller does not accept returns unless covered by eBay's Money Back Guarantee for issues like "not as described." Based on publicly available evidence, there are no signs of fake reviews or counterfeit complaints specific to this seller. Exercise usual eBay best practices due to the low price and no-return policy.
Risk Insights
Very low price vs. retail — be cautious
- Listed at $3, far below typical $10–$20 price for genuine Marvel/Mattel plush
- Such discounts can signal closeouts but also gray-market or questionable sourcing
No significant scam reports
- No direct buyer scam or counterfeit reports for grizzly_goods on eBay or public sites
Returns not accepted by seller
- Seller states 'no returns' — you rely entirely on eBay’s Money Back Guarantee if there’s a problem
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Very low price for this type of branded plush toy, which may indicate liquidation or nonstandard sourcing.
- Seller does not accept returns, increasing buyer risk unless eBay protection applies.
- Listing lacks detailed authenticity photos or close-ups of manufacturer's tag.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Identity consistency of seller across eBay and web
Score: 70
Identity consistency of seller across eBay and web
"No evidence of identity switching or masquerading detected."
Reason: Seller 'grizzly_goods' is present on eBay with a matching item history and consistent feedback, and no conflicting seller identities found.
Reputation and complaint check (scam, counterfeit, fake reviews)
Score: 70
Reputation and complaint check (scam, counterfeit, fake reviews)
"General platform reputation complaints apply to eBay widely, but not tied to this seller."
Reason: No direct scam, counterfeit, or fake review reports exist for grizzly_goods per external searches and eBay community forums.
Product authenticity red-flag check (photos, description, pricing, brand, sourcing)
Score: 50
Product authenticity red-flag check (photos, description, pricing, brand, sourcing)
"The actual item images match plausibly with genuine Mattel/Marvel design, but more detail would be required to rule out counterfeits, especially at such a low price."
Reason: Listing price is much lower than retail, seller is US-based but item is marked as 'China' origin. Description is minimal and lacks close-up authenticity evidence (e.g., tags).
Seller transaction history, inventory, and fulfillment signals
Score: 65
Seller transaction history, inventory, and fulfillment signals
"Volume indicates authentic inventory movement, though not conclusive of supply chain legitimacy."
Reason: 113 sales and a positive feedback score on this item suggest reliable fulfillment, but lack of detail means some uncertainty remains.
Return/refund policy and consumer protection
Score: 55
Return/refund policy and consumer protection
"This policy increases buyer risk in non-fraud situations (e.g. remorse returns)."
Reason: Seller does not accept returns under normal circumstances; eBay's Money Back Guarantee provides some fallback.
Legality and brand/market integrity
Score: 60
Legality and brand/market integrity
"No legal takedown or trademark complaints found associated with the listing or seller."
Reason: Item appears to follow eBay's brand/trademark rules and is described as a branded Disney/Marvel product.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Check the seller's feedback profile on eBay for recent pattern of positive/negative comments and any buyer issues.
-
2
Compare the listing’s photos and description with official Mattel/Marvel versions found on retail sites or Mattel’s site to check for details, tags, or quality differences.
-
3
Use eBay’s Money Back Guarantee if the item arrives counterfeit, damaged, or not as described—open a case promptly if problems occur.
-
4
Be cautious with 'no returns' listings, especially at unusually low prices on branded products.
Evidence & Citations
-
eBay listing for 'Marvel Mattel Spider Man Squishy Soft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 8”'
Live listing data, product details, and seller stats for grizzly_goods.
-
Web search: scam/fake review/counterfeit checks for grizzly_goods
No direct scam/counterfeit allegations found targeting this eBay seller.
-
Official Mattel/Marvel plush pricing examples (Walmart UK/US)
New Marvel/Mattel Spider-Man plush usually retails $10–$20.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Catch Amazon seller refund swap scams »Fraudulent buyers request refunds while mailing back rocks or empty boxes, tanking seller metrics. ScamAI reviews buyer...
Detect shipping label swap scams »Fraudsters send altered shipping labels or claim a swap so packages never reach the right buyer. ScamAI checks tracking...