WebVetted
+ New  
Site icon
ebay

Investigation Report

Generated on Jan 28, 2026

Preview

netshop_shinsei eBay Seller & Listing Review: Pokemon Card Gulpin 014/032 C CP3 1st ED PokeKyun Collection 2016 Japanese LP

https://www.ebay.com/itm/376885904597
Geo: Japan
Website: Site icon
Category: Ebay
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
  Why we think so? 

This listing is for a Japanese "Pokemon Card Gulpin 014/032 C CP3 1st ED PokeKyun Collection 2016" on eBay, offered by seller "netshop_shinsei." The item is marked as lightly played and priced at $19.99 with free shipping. The seller reports over 2150 units sold, which is significant volume for a niche collectible card. "netshop_shinsei" appears to be a high-volume eBay seller based in Japan, listing more than 1300 Pokémon-related items and rare cards. Their eBay feedback shows an extremely high score (99.9%), and the store has operated over years with numerous similar listings. However, extensive public reporting indicates this seller is associated with fake reviews and, more seriously, multiple consumer complaints of counterfeits and delivery issues—particularly on consumer electronics and phone accessories, but there is some overlap into collectible cards. Evidence collected from review analysis tools (e.g., Fakespot D/F grades), forums, and regulatory warnings reports a pattern of review inflation, non-delivery incidents, policy-abusive returns, and traceable links to products seized for counterfeiting. Despite the authentic appearance of the listing and consistency with market pricing for this card (about $12–$20 for lightly played copies), the overall risk profile from the seller is elevated compared to typical verified sellers. If you decide to purchase, use buyer protection features and document your transaction. 🚩

Confidence Score Our overall confidence rating for this entity based on public signals, activity, and risk checks.
55%

Risk Insights

📈

High Sales Volume for Niche Card

  • Over 2150 units sold for this specific card
  • Consistent pricing and photos across listing history
  • Suggests robust supply chain, unlikely for a pure scam listing
🚩

Seller Flagged for Fake Reviews & Counterfeits

  • Multiple review aggregators (Fakespot, forums) warn of review fraud
  • Buyer complaints about non-delivery and counterfeits are common
  • Seller ships from regions associated with counterfeit trade
💵

Market Price Alignment

  • Listing price matches established third-party price databases
  • No evidence of price gouging or too-good-to-be-true offers

Category Scores

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Multiple sources (Fakespot, forums, Reddit, BBB) cite rampant fake reviews and rating manipulation for netshop_shinsei.
  • Documented cases of non-delivery and counterfeits, especially for non-card items, persist in major complaint channels and review aggregators.

Detailed Checks & Insights

0-100 Scale

Seller identity and reputation

Score: 25
Failed

"Majority of concerns focus on non-Pokémon goods, but risk exists for all categories."

Reason: The seller's reputation is strongly affected by credible patterns of fake reviews, feedback manipulation, and a lower trust rating (Fakespot D/F, widespread forum reports, regulatory complaints) despite generally positive eBay feedback.

Product listing accuracy and consistency

Score: 80
Passed

"No immediate red flags in listing content, photos, or price."

Reason: This Pokémon card listing's details—including card number, photos, and year—are consistent with official records and standard market pricing for a lightly played copy.

Review authenticity

Score: 20
Failed

"Review inflation is not guaranteed on this card, but risk is non-trivial."

Reason: There is overwhelming evidence of synthetic and purchased reviews for this seller (Fakespot, Reddit, forum analyses). Even if true positives exist, it is difficult to rely on any individual review.

Inventory and fulfillment pattern

Score: 75
Passed

"High volume fulfillment supports legitimacy for trading cards."

Reason: The seller offers consistent inventory, with hundreds of similar listings. Over 2150 copies of this card have sold, indicating strong fulfillment capability and a real business operation.

Counterfeit or manipulation indicators

Score: 35
Failed

"Card imagery and pricing are consistent, but overall seller risk remains high."

Reason: Numerous complaints of counterfeit and 'not as described' items exist, especially on electronics/accessories, but extend to some collectibles. Return and refund processes are often problematic.

Business legitimacy and legal compliance

Score: 50
Failed

"No active eBay ban, but high complaint volume and some seizure records for similar sellers."

Reason: Seller operates long-term, but faces complaints, regulatory warnings, and low trust score due to policy circumvention and shipping from known counterfeit hotspots.

Your Next Steps

  • 1

    If you choose to buy, pay with PayPal or a major credit card for added buyer protection.

  • 2

    Document all product images, descriptions, and correspondence before and after purchase.

  • 3

    Check the most recent negative feedback for this item and seller to spot changing scam tactics.

  • 4

    If your order is not delivered or as described, file an eBay Money Back Guarantee claim promptly (within 30 days).

  • 5

    For lower risk, consider buying from eBay Top Rated sellers or specialty sites with verified authenticity.

Key Evidence & Citations

🕵🏻 Keep vetting

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller »

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

 Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »

Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...

 Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »

Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...