Investigation Report

This eBay listing offers the fragrance '9 pm by Afnan 3.4 oz EDP Cologne For Men' at $18.80, well below the $22-30 prices seen on Walmart and other major sellers. The seller, tukhtaro_47, claims a 99.8% feedback rating and has sold nearly 4,000 units of this item. Their store features a wide array of beauty, auto, and tech accessories and has 29 items for sale, shipping mainly from New York. However, deep-dive checks on scam forums and review analysis tools reveal multiple concerning signals across this seller’s broader history. Third-party feedback analysis tools flag a high proportion (up to 60%) of the seller’s reviews as potentially fake, based on suspicious patterns like text duplication and new/bulk buyer accounts. There are also frequent reports on consumer forums of counterfeit or low-grade knockoff goods, high return rates, and eBay-issued warnings for manipulated or removed feedback. Some buyers noted electronics, but also branded colognes and serums, as possible fakes or unreliable. For this specific fragrance, price and quantity sold might tempt buyers, but the broader pattern of alleged fake reviews, possible counterfeit claims, and manipulated feedback creates substantial risk. If you are looking for authenticity and a hassle-free purchase, consider established US-based sellers or authorized retailers instead. 🚩