Ebay Investigation Report
Report generated: Dec 15, 2025
eBay Seller/Listing Review: natalie_2 – All Time Low The Three Words to Remember In Dealing With The End EP CD OFFICIAL
https://www.ebay.com/itm/358004319718Why we think so?
The listing for "All Time Low The Three Words to Remember In Dealing With The End EP CD OFFICIAL" by seller natalie_2 on eBay shows several reassuring signals: clear condition notes, detailed product images (including CD and case), and the seller's 100 feedback score. No credible complaints or scam reports are found for this seller. The CD is described with specifics around disc and packaging wear. Pricing is at $700, which is high for most CDs but aligns with the rarity of this 2004 EP. The listing matches details for an authentic Emerald Moon Records release, though no inner ring/matrix close-ups are provided. The seller does not accept returns but is still covered by eBay's Money Back Guarantee for "not as described" cases. There are no strong red flags for counterfeiting or scam patterns. Buyers should still scrutinize photographs (ask for matrix code close-ups if authenticity is critical) and pay only through eBay. Overall, this listing appears reliable by eBay standards, but buyers should act with due diligence at this price level.
Risk Insights
Excellent Seller Reputation
- 100 feedback score; no public scam/fraud complaints
- Clear transaction history and visible feedback
High-Priced, Rare Collector CD
- Listing describes specific 2004 Emerald Moon Records EP
- Actual product photos with condition notes support authenticity
Protection Despite No-Returns Policy
- eBay's Money Back Guarantee applies for 'not as described'
- Return for buyer's remorse is not accepted, so be sure before purchase
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- The asking price of $700 is high, making close scrutiny and documentation of authenticity especially important.
- Seller does not accept returns, so resolution for buyer's remorse is not available outside 'not as described' claims.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller account reputation and feedback
Score: 93
Seller account reputation and feedback
"Well-established feedback and transaction history with clean public records strongly support authenticity."
Reason: The seller, natalie_2, has a feedback score of 100 and no public allegations of fraud or counterfeit activity. Reputation checks return no alerts.
Authenticity of product and description
Score: 87
Authenticity of product and description
"No matrix/hub photo is shown. If buyer demands proof of authenticity for a $700 item, they should request it pre-sale."
Reason: Detailed condition description and multiple photos are specific to the actual item (not stock). The release details match a rare All Time Low EP.
Counterfeit and scam red flags in listing patterns/content
Score: 85
Counterfeit and scam red flags in listing patterns/content
"Absence of suspicious patterns (e.g., mass listings, generic feedback, unrelated inventory) on seller page and listing."
Reason: No public complaints, scam warnings, or abnormal seller behavior patterns found. Price is high but not out of line for this rare item.
Fulfillment details and shipping reliability
Score: 88
Fulfillment details and shipping reliability
"No irregularities in shipping/fulfillment data. Buyer protection applies if delays or lost shipments occur."
Reason: The location is verifiable (Baltimore, MD, USA) and shipping details are standard for eBay. ETA and methods are in line with typical practice.
Return and protection policy clarity
Score: 79
Return and protection policy clarity
"Buyer's ability to return for remorse is restricted, but refunds remain possible for misrepresentation per eBay rules."
Reason: Listing notes 'no returns,' though eBay's Money Back Guarantee covers significant misdescription or non-delivery.
Price plausibility and comparison to market
Score: 74
Price plausibility and comparison to market
"If price seems excessive, checking comparable sales or seeking a matrix code is prudent for buyer assurance."
Reason: Price is much higher than typical standard CDs, but is within range for this rare release according to market history.
Your Next Steps
-
1
If authenticity matters, request a photo of the CD's inner ring/matrix code before purchase and compare it against known genuine copies.
-
2
Review the seller's recent feedback to verify it corresponds to similar music/media sales.
-
3
Complete your transaction using only eBay’s payment methods (PayPal, Visa, etc.) and retain all purchase records for possible dispute resolution.
-
4
If the item is received and not as described or suspected counterfeit, open a claim under eBay’s Money Back Guarantee promptly.
Evidence & Citations
-
Perplexity: Is 'natalie_2' on eBay associated with scams, fake reviews, or counterfeiting?
No credible evidence links this seller ID to scam activity or widespread complaints based on public web sources.
-
eBay Listing Detail for All Time Low EP by natalie_2
Full listing details, including price, product photos, and seller feedback, all support the presence of a legitimate offering.
-
General guidance for verifying rare CDs and preventing counterfeits
Counterfeit risks exist for rare releases; checking for matrix/hub codes and requesting photo evidence is a standard due diligence step.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...