WebVetted
+ New  
Site icon
ebay

Investigation Report

Generated on Mar 8, 2026

Preview

eBay Listing for Radiohead “The King Of Limbs” Newspaper - Seller: non_equivalent

https://www.ebay.com/itm/327022675195
Geo: Brooklyn, New York, United States
Website: Site icon
Category: Ebay
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
  Why we think so? 

This eBay listing offered Radiohead’s “The King Of Limbs” Newspaper (rare, out of print) for $9.99 plus $8 shipping, from seller 'non_equivalent' in Brooklyn, NY. The listing is marked as SOLD and shows a remarkable sales volume: 844 units sold under this listing—a very high count for a niche collector’s item. The seller, 'non_equivalent,' has a perfect eBay feedback score of 100, but public seller profile data is sparse. There are no visible reviews or ratings for this specific product, and the seller profile details are minimal—raising mild transparency concerns. The low price, high sales count, and missing feedback could be early warning signs in collector markets, where fakes and mass-produced items sometimes circulate. Still, the listing was hosted directly on eBay (which provides buyer protection and secure payment methods like PayPal and Google Pay), and there are no active scam or counterfeit reports found for this seller or the specific product. Anyone considering future listings from this seller should carefully review any available recent feedback and ask clarifying questions before purchasing. 🛡️

Confidence Score Our overall confidence rating for this entity based on public signals, activity, and risk checks.
58%

Risk Insights

⚠️

High Sales on 'Rare' Collectible Item

  • 844 units sold is inconsistent with an authentic, rare, out-of-print publication.
  • Price far below verified market rates may suggest reproductions or fakes.
  • Caution: rarity claims likely overstated; authenticity uncertain.
🔍

Opaque Seller Identity

  • No seller store details, contact info, or visible long-term feedback history.
  • 100 feedback score but no supporting reviews for this item.
  • Exercise caution—lack of traceable seller history reduces accountability.
🛡️

Marketplace Protections Apply

  • eBay and PayPal protections offer recourse for misrepresented purchases.
  • Buyers can dispute transactions and seek refunds for fakes or non-receipt.
  • Still, item authenticity must be challenged promptly for best outcome.

Category Scores

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Unusually high units sold for a 'rare' and 'out of print' item suggest the product may not be genuine or may be repros.
  • Lack of transparent seller info and missing product-specific feedback makes it harder to trust the listing’s authenticity.
  • Price is significantly below known market prices for similar genuine items, which could reflect inauthenticity or quality issues.

Detailed Checks & Insights

0-100 Scale

Seller Reputation & History

Score: 40
Failed

"Most authentic collectible-focused eBay sellers display long, detailed feedback histories. Here, only the score is visible without any supporting comments or volume, making evaluation difficult."

Reason: Seller's feedback score is technically 100 but lacks transparency: no detailed reviews or transaction history, and seller's public data is incomplete.

Sales Volume and Product Rarity Consistency

Score: 25
Failed

"Authentic rare memorabilia typically trades in much smaller quantities. Either the item is not genuine, or resold/reprinted."

Reason: Claimed sales volume (844 units) is not credible for a 'rare, out of print' collector’s publication. This sharply contradicts the expected scarcity.

Pricing Plausibility

Score: 30
Failed

"Counterfeit or unauthorized reproductions often appear at steep discounts; this price gap is risky."

Reason: The $9.99 price undercuts the only known comparable sale price by over $100; such a discount is uncommon for verified collectibles.

Review Authenticity & Buyer Feedback Pattern

Score: 35
Failed

"Legitimate listings with high volumes often have at least some visible buyer comments unless intentionally hidden or filtered."

Reason: No feedback or buyer comments are found for this specific item, and there are no reviews linked from the listing. That makes it hard to assess real buyer satisfaction or spot trends.

Fulfillment and Payment Protections

Score: 85
Passed

"eBay’s 'Money Back Guarantee' can help resolve issues for undelivered or misrepresented items, though some risks persist for collectible buyers."

Reason: Purchase and payment go through eBay, which includes escrow, PayPal/Google Pay options, and buyer protection, reducing the risk of outright fraud.

Your Next Steps

  • 1

    Before buying from 'non_equivalent' again, check their current eBay feedback for reports of counterfeits or item quality issues.

  • 2

    If you have purchased this newspaper and suspect it to be counterfeit or different than described, open a dispute through eBay’s Resolution Center promptly.

  • 3

    For collectible purchases, compare item details (images, included components) to those from reputable specialist stores or discogs.com.

  • 4

    Reconsider buying rare or collector items if the price is much lower and the volume sold is implausibly high.

Key Evidence & Citations

🕵🏻 Keep vetting