Investigation Report
Generated on Jan 27, 2026
Herman Miller Remastered Chair Size A (eBay listing by emival8)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/315288138722Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers a "Herman Miller Remastered Chair Size A" sold by user emival8 for $750 plus $200 shipping from Modesto, California. The product is described as "New 2025 Model," with 14 sales recorded and only 3 units left in stock. emival8 shows a public feedback score of 100, but seller store details are sparse and there is no visible seller store branding or prominent review presence. No complaints or scam warnings about emival8 have surfaced in public forums or review aggregators, and there’s no evidence linking this seller to fake reviews or counterfeit goods. However, the selling price is significantly below the official Herman Miller MSRP ($1,595+), and the seller does not accept returns, which is unusual for high-end products. If you proceed, use eBay’s buyer protections and verify authenticity promptly after delivery. 🛡️
Risk Insights
No scam or counterfeit complaints found
- Seller emival8 shows no public scam or counterfeit history.
- No fake review or manipulation links detected.
Major price-to-MSRP gap
- Listing undercuts Herman Miller’s standard price by over $800.
- Potential gray market or non-standard sourcing.
No returns policy
- Seller does not accept returns on a $750+ item.
- This is outside the norm for premium chair sales.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Seller offers no returns on a premium, high-value item.
- Significant price gap between seller’s listing and official Herman Miller pricing may signal non-standard sourcing.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and history clear
Score: 50
Seller identity and history clear
"A fully built-out seller profile typically includes sales history, visuals, and detailed feedback breakdowns, which are not present."
Reason: Seller feedback score is perfect, but store branding, inventory, and history information are sparse; transparency is limited.
Product and listing details consistent with brand
Score: 70
Product and listing details consistent with brand
"Pictures match standard commercial imagery for the Aeron chair. Lack of video or extra authenticity shots is a minor issue."
Reason: Images and description align with what you would expect from a 'Herman Miller Remastered Chair Size A', but the discount is notable.
Pricing in expected range for genuine item
Score: 30
Pricing in expected range for genuine item
"New, authentic Aeron Remastered chairs from Herman Miller retail for $1,595+. This listing is $750 (+$200 shipping), raising questions about sourcing or authenticity."
Reason: Price is about 50% of official MSRP for a new model, which is well below typical authorized reseller prices for this brand.
Return/refund policy reasonable for product risk
Score: 10
Return/refund policy reasonable for product risk
"Most legitimate furniture sellers, even used, provide at least limited return windows."
Reason: No returns offered. This creates high risk for buyers of expensive office furniture, as authentic items should have return protection.
Independent scam/complaint evidence
Score: 80
Independent scam/complaint evidence
"Web search did not surface any negative patterns for emival8; risk profile appears ordinary, not high."
Reason: No external mentions in scam lists, forums, or product complaint databases related to emival8.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Check the official feedback page for emival8 to confirm transaction history and read buyer comments for this specific item.
-
2
Compare listing images with those on Herman Miller’s website or authorized dealers to spot signs of counterfeiting.
-
3
If purchasing, use eBay’s supported payment methods with buyer protection.
-
4
On receipt, review item condition and features closely; contact eBay immediately if you spot anything suspicious.
-
5
Consider contacting Herman Miller’s customer service to confirm product authenticity using serial/model numbers.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Seller Feedback Score and Profile: emival8
⤷ Direct link to seller’s profile and recent feedback for a detailed look at transaction quality.
-
Herman Miller Official Pricing
⤷ Official retail pricing for proper price comparison.
-
General eBay Platform Reviews
⤷ Overall platform issues (not seller-specific) such as delivery times and return problems.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...