Investigation Report
Generated on Apr 19, 2026
ShoesandFashions eBay Listing for Motion Performance 1/4 Zip johnnie-O Mens (7851787)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/298152471534Why we think so?
ShoesandFashions is a high-volume eBay seller based in Rocky Mount, United States, with a substantial inventory and a feedback score of 98.5%. The specific listing for the Motion Performance 1/4 Zip johnnie-O Mens is marked 'new with tags,' aligns visually and textually with the authentic brand item, but is listed at $64.99—about half the typical retail price found elsewhere ($128–$138). While the seller enjoys a large quantity of sales and maintains a strong feedback record, there are isolated consumer complaints online alleging counterfeit goods. There is no direct evidence of fake reviews, but buyers should note the pricing mismatch and one report of inauthentic products. The store offers standard payment and return policies, and the bulk of their sales appear legitimate. Proceed, but with awareness: snagging a deep discount from a mega-seller carries some risk, so inspect your item upon arrival and make use of eBay's buyer protection if anything feels off.
Risk Insights
Deep Discount – Check Authenticity
- Item price is about 50% below typical retail.
- Lower price could signal grey market or counterfeit goods.
- Always verify product branding, packaging, tags.
Bulk Sales, Mostly Positive
- Seller holds 98.5% positive feedback across 93,000+ ratings.
- High volume makes large-scale scamming less likely.
- Still, a single negative outlier can matter—research recent reviews.
Standard eBay Protections Apply
- 30-day returns and major payment options accepted.
- eBay and PayPal dispute processes are available to buyers.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Listing price is well below the typical brand retail price for the same item, which is a classic indicator of possible counterfeit risk.
- Documented online complaint alleging ShoesandFashions shipped counterfeit product despite high seller status.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and eBay track record
Score: 92
Seller identity and eBay track record
"High-volume, public-facing eBay seller. Storefront and items indicate legitimate large-retail business."
Reason: ShoesandFashions has a long-standing presence, thousands of transactions, and a 98.5% positive feedback score.
Authenticity of product and risk of counterfeits
Score: 52
Authenticity of product and risk of counterfeits
"While many transactions go smoothly, the price difference and risk calls for caution."
Reason: The item is priced well below official retail and there is a documented but isolated counterfeit complaint.
Review and feedback manipulation
Score: 85
Review and feedback manipulation
"Some eBay products attract fake review activity in general, but none specifically tie to ShoesandFashions."
Reason: No direct evidence of fake reviews or feedback manipulation for this seller.
Listing details and commercial transparency
Score: 75
Listing details and commercial transparency
"Standard information, photos, and buyer protections are presented as expected for a high-volume seller."
Reason: Listing matches official product description and images. Pricing and stock are clearly stated.
Legal disclosures and buyer protections
Score: 83
Legal disclosures and buyer protections
"No legal issues detected, buyer protections in place."
Reason: eBay transaction includes a 30-day return policy, standard payment options, and buyer recourse.
Business validity and fulfillment risk
Score: 65
Business validity and fulfillment risk
"Recommend inspecting the product and using buyer protections if anything seems wrong."
Reason: The seller’s volume and store size indicate a real business, but the low price and isolated counterfeit complaint are risk factors.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Verify the product for authenticity when it arrives (compare with official johnnie-O tags, quality, and packaging).
-
2
If the item appears off (poor stitching, wrong tags, odd smell), contact eBay support and consider a return immediately.
-
3
Take photos of the packaging and product before removing tags to help with any disputes.
-
4
Check your PayPal or credit card protection policies for additional recourse.
-
5
Review seller feedback for recent comments mentioning counterfeits or issues.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
ConsumerAffairs review referencing ShoesandFashions counterfeit complaint
⤷ A reviewer explicitly claimed ShoesandFashions sent counterfeit goods, but this is a single unverified complaint among many positive transactions.
-
Official johnnie-O Motion Performance 1/4 Zip retail pricing
⤷ Brand store lists item for $128–$138, much higher than the eBay listing.
-
ShoesandFashions eBay Storefront
⤷ Seller holds a 98.5% positive feedback score and a high sales volume.
-
eBay listing Motion Performance 1/4 Zip johnnie-O Mens
⤷ Listing shows item as new with tags, offering standard returns and payment through major methods.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.