Investigation Report
Generated on May 4, 2026
Baldur’s Gate 3 Valentines Astarion Plush (9in) Youtooz – xigutoys (eBay Listing)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/287250477036Why we think so?
This listing offers the "Baldur’s Gate 3 Valentines Astarion Plush (9in) Youtooz" from seller xigutoys on eBay. The item is marked as new and is priced at $150, while the original retail price was $29.99 from Youtooz (now sold out). The seller has 46 sales of this plush and a 100 feedback score, but their eBay profile page and broader product history are sparse. The product is physically located in Huizhou, China, and the listing includes multiple genuine-looking photos. Payment options include PayPal and major credit cards, and a 30-day return policy is available, aligning with eBay protections. No direct evidence of counterfeit or fraudulent activity is found for xigutoys, but the price markup and limited seller history warrant caution. 🛡️ Proceed carefully, verify all information, and consider buyer protections before purchase.
Risk Insights
Price Markup Signals Caution
- Listed at $150—significantly over original $29.99 retail.
- Such markups common for rare collectibles, but often draw scammers too.
- Research recent sales to set expectations.
Low Public Seller History
- xigutoys has limited visible transaction history.
- No off-eBay presence or additional info found.
- Review feedback page closely for signs of legitimacy.
Standard eBay Protections Apply
- Payments through PayPal/eBay—no signs of off-platform requests.
- 30-day return option present (buyer pays return shipping).
- Use platform tools to resolve disputes.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Price is five times original retail, which can indicate either legitimate scarcity or opportunistic reselling. This warrants investigation before committing.
- Sparse public seller history makes it hard to verify long-term trustworthiness of xigutoys.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity verification
Score: 50
Seller identity verification
"Unable to verify identity or extended presence beyond selected listings."
Reason: Seller xigutoys has a valid eBay username and feedback, but lacks deep public history and store metadata.
Seller reputation (feedback, account age, legitimacy)
Score: 40
Seller reputation (feedback, account age, legitimacy)
"Limited to eBay platform; cannot cross-check history on external sources."
Reason: 100 feedback score looks good, but no transparency about broader seller tenure or reviews from outside this transaction set.
Product consistency and authenticity (price, photos, details)
Score: 75
Product consistency and authenticity (price, photos, details)
"No evidence of stock or fake images; physical details consistent with manufacturer."
Reason: Listing matches the official Youtooz item; images likely original and multiple angles provided. The price is much higher than original retail, but photos do match authentic products.
Review authenticity and buyer feedback
Score: 45
Review authenticity and buyer feedback
"Feedback is generic and not product-specific."
Reason: No detailed item reviews are listed, no cluster patterns or obvious fake reviews detected, but overall review volume is low.
Fulfillment and returns (policy, payment, delivery risk)
Score: 80
Fulfillment and returns (policy, payment, delivery risk)
"Follow eBay channel for buyer protection—avoid shipment/payment outside platform."
Reason: Listing supports standard eBay and PayPal payments, and offers a 30-day return option. No evidence of requests for off-platform payment.
Counterfeit/manipulation/complaints activity
Score: 75
Counterfeit/manipulation/complaints activity
"No verified reports of counterfeit Youtooz plush from this seller to date."
Reason: Web and review searches do not show specific scam or counterfeit complaints about xigutoys.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Check the seller’s full feedback and history for multiple completed sales of similar plush items.
-
2
Use eBay’s buyer protection—only pay through eBay or PayPal; do not agree to off-platform payments.
-
3
Compare with recent sales/prices of the same plush on eBay, Etsy, and collectible forums to set expectations.
-
4
Contact the seller to request additional photos or proof of item possession, if still unsure.
-
5
Report suspicious listings to eBay if the seller pushes for external payments or unusual communication.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Expert advice on eBay fakes and review manipulation
⤷ Covers general red flags for seller authenticity—no direct complaints about xigutoys found.
-
Official Youtooz pricing for Astarion plush
⤷ Confirms original retail price and current sold-out status.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.