Investigation Report
Generated on Jan 29, 2026
eBay Seller 'renfrance48' – Vintage Orient 3 Star Automatic 21 Jewels Day Date Black Dial Japan Watch Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/287107032513Why we think so?
This listing for a "Vintage Orient 3 Star Automatic 21 Jewels Day Date Black Dial Japan Watch" came from seller 'renfrance48' on eBay. The price was $75 with $10.15 shipping, and the item was marked "Pre-owned - Excellent". Although the item has already sold out (122 sold), and the seller boasts over 10,000 sales with feedback appearing at ~98.8% positive, there are serious warning signs. Multiple independent sources point to large-scale fake reviews, counterfeit goods—including luxury brands and watches—and repeated complaints about manipulated feedback. As of early 2026, tools like Fakespot grade the seller poorly, and both eBay and third-party forums list numerous red flags. The listed watch's price is slightly below the typical $110-$140 range seen on other trusted marketplaces, which could be a lure. Potential buyers face elevated scam and counterfeit risks, so strong caution is advised. 🚨
Risk Insights
Fake Review Manipulation Detected
- 40-60% of feedback estimated to be inauthentic.
- Repeated review text and suspicious reviewer activity detected.
Counterfeit Product Risk
- Seller widely reported for selling fakes across luxury categories.
- 200+ negative buyer reports cite 'cheap replica' or 'not as described'.
Below-Market Price Concern
- Listing price ($75) is lower than expected range for authentic vintage Orient 3 Star models.
- Could indicate product quality or authenticity issues.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Multiple complaints and external investigations tie the seller to fake review manipulation and the sale of counterfeit products.
- Price is below typical market rates, raising suspicion about authenticity especially for vintage watches.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller history and authenticity
Score: 20
Seller history and authenticity
"Although the seller has over 10,000 sales, quality of reviews is dubious and eBay/other watchdogs have repeatedly flagged fraudulent activity."
Reason: The seller has a sizeable history, but most of their reputation is undermined by independent evidence of long-running fake reviews and policy violations for counterfeits.
Review authenticity and manipulation
Score: 15
Review authenticity and manipulation
"Patterns include repeated review text, suspicious reviewer accounts, and feedback spikes tied to certain branded listings."
Reason: Feedback is heavily manipulated—Fakespot grades seller D/F, estimates show up to 60% of recent reviews are fake or shill-submitted.
Product pricing and consistency with market
Score: 35
Product pricing and consistency with market
"Price may be used to entice buyers; combined with the seller's poor reputation, risk increases."
Reason: While not an outlier for all items, the Orient watch is priced at $75, below normal for comparable vintage models ($112-$142). This is a red flag considering seller reputation.
Counterfeit, replica, or scam complaints
Score: 10
Counterfeit, replica, or scam complaints
"Complaints include US customs issues, items matching known counterfeit models, and refusal to refund buyers."
Reason: The seller is repeatedly cited in scam, BBB, and Reddit reports for selling counterfeits, especially luxury goods (watches, bags, shoes).
Photos and product description accuracy
Score: 55
Photos and product description accuracy
"Product images are consistent and do not immediately show signs of photoshop or obvious fakes for this individual watch; description is sparse."
Reason: Listing photos match common stock for Orient 3 Star watches, and factual descriptors are given, albeit with minimal detail.
Fulfillment, shipping, and return policy analysis
Score: 40
Fulfillment, shipping, and return policy analysis
"Watch listed as shipping from Indiana, but pattern of drop-shipping and untracked parcels is part of wider seller complaint record."
Reason: No returns are accepted despite a high fraud risk, and buyer complaints cite shipping issues like untracked parcels from China and refusal to honor eBay protections.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Avoid purchasing from this seller, especially high-value or branded items—risk of counterfeit and scam is high.
-
2
If you have bought from renfrance48, file a claim through eBay's Money Back Guarantee immediately and document all communications.
-
3
Report suspicious activity or counterfeit concerns directly to eBay via the seller profile 'Report' button.
-
4
Always double-check vintage or luxury watch authenticity with independent verification tools—avoid deals much cheaper than market average unless provenance can be proven.
-
5
Consider running listings through Fakespot, ReviewMeta, or search eBay/Reddit for recent scam complaints about the seller.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Seller Overview: renfrance48 on eBay
⤷ Details about fake review manipulation, counterfeit items, and general scam risks cited from crowdsourced and independent e-commerce watchdogs.
-
Vintage Orient 3 Star Pricing Across Marketplaces
⤷ Market price comparison shows the typical range for authentic vintage watches is significantly higher than the eBay listing.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...