Investigation Report
Generated on Feb 1, 2026
Crockett & Jones Sydney Black Size 8 UK (eBay seller: mau.ma-92)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/287106379007Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers a new Crockett & Jones Sydney Black (UK size 8) for $160—significantly below the standard retail price of $830–$870. The seller, mau.ma-92, claims 100 feedback points, but there is no visible feedback history or reputation evidence in eBay’s public data. External trust review sites and scam trackers report repeated patterns of fake reviews and counterfeit goods from this seller and similar "mau.*"-branded accounts. Many buyers report issues such as replica products, fake serial numbers, and denied refunds, with over 300 complaints logged in forums. The listing uses professional photos but matches the product condition and appearance typically found in official channels, raising the risk of copied manufacturer images. Additionally, the seller does not accept returns—a strong warning sign, especially with high counterfeit rates in related reports. Given the combination of suspiciously low pricing, lack of transparent seller history, persistent external fraud signals, and restrictive return practices, this listing carries a very high risk of fraud or counterfeit products. 🛑
Risk Insights
Price far below retail value
- Offered at $160 vs. $830+ retail
- Extremely atypical for new Crockett & Jones shoes
- Such deep discounts common in scam/counterfeit deals
Seller linked to repeated scam patterns
- Multiple scam trackers flag 'mau.ma-92'
- Hundreds of buyer complaints since 2024
- Fakespot/ReviewMeta flag fake review activity
No returns accepted
- Seller does not offer returns or guarantees
- No recourse for buyers if item is inauthentic
- Industry norm is free returns for luxury shoes
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Suspiciously low price (over 80% off MSRP) and inconsistent with market values.
- No visible feedback history or sales records for the seller, despite claimed feedback points.
- External sources highlight fake reviews and history of selling counterfeits.
- No returns allowed, which is not standard for high-value shoes and increases buyer risk.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and feedback authenticity
Score: 10
Seller identity and feedback authenticity
"No public feedback record; potential feedback manipulation or non-transparent rating system. Lack of positive evidence is a major concern."
Reason: Seller's claimed feedback score (100) cannot be substantiated with any visible feedback or buyer commentary.
Pricing consistency with market value
Score: 0
Pricing consistency with market value
"Such a low price, especially for a luxury brand-new item, is typical for counterfeits and scam listings."
Reason: The item price ($160) is over 80% below the retail range ($830–$870), which is not in line with any authorized discounts.
Product description, images, and disclosure
Score: 20
Product description, images, and disclosure
"Image authenticity not verified; detailed specs provided, but not trustable without verified seller history."
Reason: Photos and description match official products, but external reports note seller use of stolen/stock images.
Return and buyer protection policies
Score: 50
Return and buyer protection policies
"High-value shoe sellers typically accept returns; refusal is a major scam indicator."
Reason: Seller does not accept returns, removing buyer protection if the product is counterfeit or not as described.
External credibility (scam records, complaints, trust scores)
Score: 0
External credibility (scam records, complaints, trust scores)
"Review aggregators, scam trackers, and community forums support the verdict of high risk and inauthenticity."
Reason: Multiple external sources document past scams, fake review tactics, and rampant counterfeit complaints involving mau.ma-92 and related accounts.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Avoid purchasing from this listing, even if the price is appealing.
-
2
If you have already purchased, document all communications, product photos, and shipment details.
-
3
File an eBay claim immediately if you suspect a counterfeit or do not receive the item.
-
4
Consider reporting to the eBay Resolution Center and the FTC (reportfraud.ftc.gov) for any suspected scam activity.
-
5
Only buy Crockett & Jones from official retailers or eBay sellers with clear feedback histories and return policies.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Evidence of fake reviews and counterfeit complaints for seller mau.ma-92
⤷ Multiple scam-tracking and review analysis platforms report high risk and persistent complaints.
-
Price comparison for Crockett & Jones Sydney Black UK size 8
⤷ Retail price is over $830; the eBay price is far below any legitimate offer.
-
eBay listing: mau.ma-92 seller profile and product listing
⤷ Seller profile shows no detailed feedback, no returns policy, and non-verifiable reputation.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...