Investigation Report
Generated on Jan 25, 2026
makeitmakescents444 eBay Seller & YSL Y Le Parfum Eau de Parfum Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/277670579417Why we think so?
The eBay seller makeitmakescents444 offers a sealed bottle of YSL Y Le Parfum Eau de Parfum (100ml) for $99.99, with 680 units sold and a high feedback score of 98.7%. The listing appears professionally formatted, includes multiple clear images, and offers payment via recognized services like PayPal, Google Pay, and credit cards. However, the seller does not accept returns, which is a caution signal for high-value fragrance purchases. The price is comparable to reputable European retailers but higher than some UK/EU deals, though much lower than the official YSL site. No direct evidence of fake reviews or counterfeit goods has surfaced, but perfume is a high-risk category for counterfeiting on secondary markets. Buyers are protected via eBay’s payment systems, but due diligence is still advised—especially since the seller’s return policy is very restrictive.
Risk Insights
Buyer protection applies, but no returns
- eBay's buyer protection still covers you if you receive a fake.
- Seller does not accept returns, so you'll need strong evidence if filing a case.
Volume hints at possible gray market sourcing
- Over 680 bottles sold—unusual for an individual eBay seller.
- Likely not an official YSL distributor.
Competitive but not suspiciously low price
- Price is similar to EU gray market retailers but much less than YSL direct.
- Aligns with typical eBay 'gray market' pricing, not too-good-to-be-true.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- No returns accepted—limits buyer recourse for potential counterfeit/discrepancy.
- High sales volume of sealed luxury fragrances without an official distributor relationship may indicate increased risk of fake items.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller Identity Verification
Score: 70
Seller Identity Verification
"Account uses an individual-style username, not a business name, but has a sales history and a verified eBay profile."
Reason: The seller is a long-standing eBay user with a robust feedback score, though the business entity behind the account is unclear.
Seller Reputation & Feedback Authenticity
Score: 65
Seller Reputation & Feedback Authenticity
"Feedback score of 98.7% is strong; no concentrated bursts of negative feedback suggesting widespread issues."
Reason: Feedback is generally positive and reflects hundreds of transactions, though deeper review authenticity cannot be confirmed.
Listing Detail & Photo Consistency
Score: 85
Listing Detail & Photo Consistency
"Multiple images, including box and bottle; 'sealed' status claimed."
Reason: Photos are clear, appear original (not stock), and product metadata matches standard product details found on other sites.
Inventory & Sales Pattern
Score: 60
Inventory & Sales Pattern
"Does not appear to be an authorized YSL retailer to support such volume."
Reason: Selling 680+ units of luxury sealed perfume is unusual for an individual seller and could indicate gray market or non-retail sources.
Product Price vs. Market
Score: 75
Product Price vs. Market
"UK: £65-£90, official YSL: €125. This listing: $99.99. Price is plausible but signals gray market supply."
Reason: Price is competitive compared to EU sellers and much lower than YSL official, though not suspiciously low versus other gray market vendors.
Return & Buyer Protection Policies
Score: 50
Return & Buyer Protection Policies
"eBay buyer protection applies, but a seller-backed return option would be safer for high-risk items like perfume."
Reason: Return policy is very restrictive; the seller does not accept returns, which reduces options for recourse.
Legal, Brand, and Authenticity Risks
Score: 60
Legal, Brand, and Authenticity Risks
"No credible blacklists or scam reports for this seller; gray market sourcing suspected."
Reason: No direct proof of counterfeit activity, but high-volume fragrance sales by non-authorized sellers always carry risk.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Request detailed photos of the product box including batch/serial numbers to compare against official YSL packaging before buying.
-
2
Use eBay’s buyer protection policy and pay via covered payment methods like PayPal or credit card.
-
3
Inspect the received item carefully for authenticity (scent, packaging, serial codes). If counterfeit is suspected, file a dispute with eBay immediately.
-
4
Purchase from official retailers or those with a clearly stated returns policy if you want maximum safety for expensive fragrances.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
makeitmakescents444 eBay Product Listing
⤷ Primary source for product and seller metadata, sales history, and listing policies.
-
makeitmakescents444 eBay Seller Profile
⤷ Shows feedback, but little store branding or additional seller data found.
-
Perplexity search: Counterfeit and Review Risks for this seller
⤷ General findings on fragrance counterfeits and what to check; no specific red flags for this seller.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...