Ebay Due Diligence
Report for Piratej18
Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers a used Banpresto DXF Servant Figure Vol. 1 Saber for $20 plus $9.06 shipping, sold by the user piratej18 based in Annapolis, Maryland. The seller profile indicates a 100% positive feedback rating and a sales history on eBay dating back to September 2000, with nearly 200 units of this figure sold. No direct evidence of counterfeit sales or scam complaints was found in public search results. The listing includes detailed product images, standard payment options, but no stated returns policy. The price is significantly below the typical $55–$60 range reported by other sites for this figure, which may signal a deal or raise authenticity questions. For buyers, it's important to review the photos closely, ask about official branding (such as authentication stickers), and factor in the seller's no-returns policy before purchase. eBay's strong buyer protection can help in case the item does not match its description.
Risk Insights
Veteran, High-Feedback Seller 🛡️
- piratej18 has been active on eBay since 2000.
- 100% positive feedback with no scam accusations.
- Nearly 200 sales for this listing alone.
Suspiciously Low Price
- Figure listed for $20; typical retail is around $55–$60.
- Low price could suggest bootleg risk.
- Carefully compare listing images to official references.
Buyer Protection & No Returns
- No returns accepted by this seller.
- eBay and PayPal protection still apply.
- Save records and communicate in-platform for safety.
Contradictory Signals
The unusually low price and no-returns policy are riskier than expected for such a well-established seller, but could be explained by item condition or overstock.
Signal A: The seller is established, highly-rated, and has a long history with no negative reports.
Signal B: The figure price is far below market average and seller refuses returns.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- The figure is listed at roughly 1/3 the price commonly found at specialty retailers (typically $55–$60), which could be a signal for potential counterfeits unless otherwise explained.
- The seller does not accept returns, reducing options for buyers if the item is not as described.
🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis
Seller account age and feedback history
Score: 100/100
Seller account age and feedback history
"This history makes fraud highly unlikely unless the account was compromised."
Reason: piratej18 is a veteran eBay seller active for over two decades with a perfect feedback record.
Seller reputation and scam signals
Score: 90/100
Seller reputation and scam signals
"Multiple web queries produced no stories, complaints, or legal warnings tied to this seller."
Reason: No scam complaints, fraud accusations, or negative news found for this seller across web and eBay searches.
Product price compared to market value
Score: 40/100
Product price compared to market value
"The low price is the main outlier and, in collectible markets, can sometimes signal bootlegs unless justified by condition or other factors."
Reason: Listing is priced at $20 versus the ~$55–$60 prices reported for the same figure from reputable sources.
Listing images and product consistency
Score: 85/100
Listing images and product consistency
"Compare listing images closely with official Banpresto references before purchasing."
Reason: Multiple images provided, including close-ups, match the product’s expected appearance, though lack of unambiguous authenticity marks means due diligence is still recommended.
Listing details, buyer protection, returns, and shipping
Score: 80/100
Listing details, buyer protection, returns, and shipping
"No returns increases buyer risk, so use protected payment methods and keep communication in-platform."
Reason: Standard eBay payments accepted and buyer protection available, but return policy is strict (no returns).
Sales volume and fulfillment pattern
Score: 88/100
Sales volume and fulfillment pattern
"This suggests fulfillment is consistent and traceable."
Reason: Listing has nearly 200 completed sales with no pattern of negative feedback.
Web search for seller and item complaints
Score: 91/100
Web search for seller and item complaints
"Multiple web sources searched, no relevant negative results for either seller or product."
Reason: No allegations or suspicious reviews associated with seller or listing found online.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Carefully inspect all listing photos for authenticity stickers and compare details (paint, seams) to official Banpresto references.
-
2
Contact the seller (piratej18) and request close-up images of any authenticity markings or stickers if not clearly shown.
-
3
If concerned about authenticity or buyer protection, purchase using PayPal or another protected payment method.
-
4
Keep records of all communication and consider eBay’s buyer protection program if issues arise after purchase.
Evidence & Citations
-
Perplexity: Seller Reputation Analysis
Confirms seller history, feedback and lack of negative reports.
-
Banpresto Figure Authenticity Tips
Explains how to spot counterfeit anime figures including Banpresto.
-
Current Listing and Sales Data
Provided listing price, sales count, and return policy details.
🕵🏻 Keep investigating
Vet TikTok, eBay, Amazon, or Facebook Marketplace storefronts.
Detect dropshipped quality-switch scams on TikTok ShopSome shops advertise brand-name goods but ship random factory surplus once they capture payment. ScamAI looks at fulfill...
Read playbook → Expose fake brand storefronts on TikTok ShopFake shops borrow official brand names, then redirect to off-platform checkout links. ScamAI inspects registration docs,...
Read playbook →