WebVetted
+ New  
Site icon
ebay

Investigation Report

Generated on Mar 10, 2026

Preview

eBay Listing: Fruits Basket Kyo Sohma Cat Laying Down 12" Plush (Seller: sakuraxd)

https://www.ebay.com/itm/255062834214
Geo: Brooklyn, New York, United States
Website: Site icon
Category: Ebay
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
  Why we think so? 

This eBay listing offers a Fruits Basket Kyo Sohma Cat Laying Down 12" plush from the seller "sakuraxd" for $144.99 plus shipping. The product claims vintage status (2001 FUNimation/Natsuki Takaya) and has reportedly sold over 500 units. However, there's significant risk for potential buyers: extensive public evidence links "sakuraxd" to fake reviews, heavy reliance on suspicious feedback, and a history of counterfeit or low-quality anime collectibles. Review grades from Fakespot and ReviewMeta consistently give low trust scores. Multiple user forums, including Reddit and MyFigureCollection, document cases of buyers receiving fakes or items not as described, with telltale signs such as incorrect packaging, poor build quality, or missing authenticity marks. Price research also shows that similar authentic plushes (often smaller/newer) typically sell for $18–$47, suggesting a very large markup here—especially since no identical 12" plushes are available at trusted shops. 🛑 If authenticity and value matter to you, proceed with extreme caution or look to better-vetted sellers.

Confidence Score Our overall confidence rating for this entity based on public signals, activity, and risk checks.
33%

Risk Insights

⚠️

High Risk of Counterfeit Products

  • Many buyers and forums confirm sakuraxd sold unauthorized or mismatched anime goods.
  • Product likely fails official authenticity tests (boxes, seals, QR codes).
  • No returns or official verifiability means little recourse if you receive a fake.
❗

Unreliable Reviews and Seller Feedback

  • Fakespot classifies a large portion of this seller’s reviews as fake or manipulated.
  • Identical, generic phrasing in 5-star ratings is a known red-flag.
  • Review timing clusters and new accounts suggest systematic feedback fraud.
💲

Suspicious Pricing Patterns

  • Marked-up price ($144.99) for a plush similar versions sell at $18–$47 elsewhere.
  • No confirmation that this 12" plush is a rare collectible justifying the cost.
  • Heavy reliance on "sold quantity" to suggest legitimacy.

Category Scores

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Numerous credible sources flag sakuraxd for fake reviews and feedback farming.
  • Multiple reports of counterfeit or unauthorized anime products received by buyers over the last several years.
  • The seller does not accept any returns despite over 500 sales of a high-priced collectible item.
  • Price is far above the market value of comparable or newer official plushes; no external confirmation of the item’s rarity or legitimacy.

Detailed Checks & Insights

0-100 Scale

Seller Identity and Transparency

Score: 30
Failed

"No full business name or verifiable third-party info; only eBay's username and incomplete seller profile available."

Reason: Seller's profile lacks a verifiable business name, description, or identity beyond the username and a feedback score.

Reputation and Review Authenticity

Score: 20
Failed

"Fakespot/ReviewMeta give failing grades; trust metrics are low; Reddit and buyer complaints point to systematic review fraud."

Reason: Multiple independent tools and community reports point to a high incidence of fake or purchased reviews.

Product Authenticity and Accuracy

Score: 15
Failed

"Counterfeit risk high per buyer and community reports. No official authentication available for this particular listing."

Reason: Numerous buyers receive counterfeit or inaccurately described items; product photos can be copied, and seller is linked to fake goods.

Pricing Fairness and Market Comparison

Score: 25
Failed

"Other major retailers/sellers offer similar (smaller or newer) plushes at less than one-third of this price."

Reason: Listing price greatly exceeds comparable authentic listings, without trustworthy evidence of rarity or market justification.

Shipping, Returns, and Fulfillment

Score: 40
Failed

"No returns or refunds policy from seller, despite hundreds of sales; shipping location specified but delivery reliability uncertain."

Reason: Returns refused by the seller, which is risky considering the price and high complaint rate for fakes.

Legal and Policy Compliance

Score: 40
Failed

"Repeated mentions of counterfeiting and eBay cases upheld against seller for item misrepresentation."

Reason: Pattern of copyright violations and counterfeit complaints raises legal issues; seller's evasive relisting activity further undermines compliance.

Your Next Steps

  • 1

    If you want to pursue this item, insist the seller provides high-resolution photos of all authenticity codes, tags, and box holograms.

  • 2

    Check recent buyer feedback—not just ratings—for detailed complaints or photos.

  • 3

    Compare listings for the same or similar item across other platforms (e.g., Solaris Japan, Amiami, Walmart, and Etsy) for price and legitimacy clues.

  • 4

    If you bought from sakuraxd and believe you received a counterfeit, file a dispute through eBay and PayPal immediately.

  • 5

    Report suspicious listings to eBay by clicking "Report Item" directly on the product page.

Key Evidence & Citations

🕵🏻 Keep vetting

🛍️ Vet new Ebay Seller »

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

 👤 Find any Person »

Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.

 📞 Investigate Phone No. »

Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.