Investigation Report
Generated on Apr 12, 2026
eBay Seller/Listing Analysis: co_84235 – BULLY TOOLS 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel
https://www.ebay.com/itm/227283472739Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers a BULLY TOOLS 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel with a fiberglass handle from the seller "co_84235," based in Springdale, Arkansas. The item is priced at $39.59 and marked as new, but the listing uses generic, manufacturer-like photos and provides little descriptive detail. Notably, the seller does not accept returns, and their profile is minimally filled out without a visible store name, ratings, or feedback history. The price is considerably below major retailers like Gemplers ($54.99) or the official Bully Tools site ($55.99–$58.99), suggesting either an unusually good deal or a possible risk. No scam complaints are found, but the lack of seller transparency and price gap call for caution. 🛒
Risk Insights
Price is far below retail
- eBay price: $39.59; next lowest Gemplers: $54.99; official site: $55.99–$58.99
- Such a discount on a new branded product is unusual and should prompt scrutiny.
Seller has no visible reputation
- No feedback score, reviews, or store branding for "co_84235"
- Impossible to assess buyer satisfaction or trustworthiness.
Returns not accepted
- Return policy is stricter than typical for new retail goods
- Reduces buyer protection if problems arise.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- No seller ratings, reviews, or sales history visible for "co_84235."
- Price is significantly below the lowest price at reputable U.S. retailers for the same shovel.
- Returns not accepted, which is rare for a new, branded product.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity is clear and verifiable
Score: 40
Seller identity is clear and verifiable
"Makes verification or reputation checking difficult."
Reason: Seller's eBay profile does not list a store name, ratings, or feedback. The username is generic and there's no traceable business info.
Positive and authentic seller reputation
Score: 42
Positive and authentic seller reputation
"Authenticity of past transactions can't be established."
Reason: No visible ratings, feedback, or review history. Unable to assess trust based on reputation.
Product listing is detailed, clear, and internally consistent
Score: 50
Product listing is detailed, clear, and internally consistent
"Does not help establish item location or proof of possession."
Reason: Listing has minimal description and uses manufacturer images only.
Listing conditions and price match market norms for the item
Score: 40
Listing conditions and price match market norms for the item
"Low price could indicate gray market, overstock, or higher risk."
Reason: Price is much lower than official and major seller prices for the identical model. Seller does not accept returns.
Evidence of legitimate fulfillment/past delivery
Score: 50
Evidence of legitimate fulfillment/past delivery
"Not enough data to judge fulfillment reliability."
Reason: Only one recorded sale and no visible buyer feedback on this listing.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Do not purchase unless you can independently confirm the legitimacy of the seller. Consider contacting them with a product-specific question.
-
2
Check the official Bully Tools website and authorized sellers for price and authenticity information.
-
3
If you choose to buy, use a payment method with strong buyer protection (such as PayPal or a credit card).
-
4
Avoid listings where the seller profile lacks history, detailed information, or feedback unless the risk is acceptable to you.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
BULLY TOOLS Model Pricing Across Sellers
⤷ Gemplers lists the shovel at $54.99, manufacturer site at $55.99–$58.99; eBay price ($39.59) is well under market.
-
eBay seller co_84235 profile
⤷ Seller profile lacks ratings, reviews, or detailed business info.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.