Investigation Report
Generated on Apr 2, 2026
shesbie_20 (eBay Seller) – RTX 5070 Ti 16G Gaming Trio OC Plus Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/227275326336Why we think so?
This eBay listing for an "MSI NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5070 Ti 16G Gaming Trio OC Plus Graphics Card-GDDR7" is being sold by user shesbie_20 for $600, which is far below the $850–$1400 retail prices at reputable retailers. Several warning signs stand out: - The seller has a feedback score of 0, indicating no history of successful transactions or customer trust. - External investigations flag this seller for widespread use of fake reviews, review manipulation, and delivery of counterfeit or misrepresented products. Numerous Reddit and Trustpilot reports (2024–2026) point to review farming and counterfeit items across their inventory. - The return policy is strict — no returns accepted — and there is no meaningful seller profile or verifiable contact details. High-quality stock images are used for the listing, which commonly conceal the true condition of the shipped product. - Price is far below market rates, and past buyer complaints include receiving knockoffs instead of advertised goods, poor quality, slow/absent seller communication, and issues obtaining refunds. Given these risks and extensive, recent negative signals, this listing and seller present a very high likelihood of being a scam or source of counterfeits. 🛑 Strongly avoid purchasing from this seller.
Risk Insights
Widespread Counterfeit Reports
- Multiple buyers received fake or misrepresented products.
- Professional stock images used to conceal product quality.
- Strong scam consensus from independent review/BBB sources.
Zero Feedback Seller, No Return Policy
- No evidence of prior successful transactions.
- No returns accepted; poor support per buyer reports.
- Price far below reputable sources.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Widespread reports of fake reviews and scam complaints against seller shesbie_20.
- eBay feedback score of 0 (no transaction trust established).
- Listing price is much lower than market value for this product.
- No returns accepted and no seller profile or real contact information provided.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity & feedback legitimacy
Score: 50
Seller identity & feedback legitimacy
"A credible seller should have verifiable positive feedback and transaction history. This seller has none."
Reason: The seller's eBay account (shesbie_20) has a feedback score of 0 and no records of past transactions. Extensive independent reports accuse them of review manipulation and impersonation.
Product authenticity and stock evidence
Score: 10
Product authenticity and stock evidence
"Serious risk of receiving counterfeit or non-authentic goods."
Reason: External investigation and buyer claims show this seller's previous listings often use stock images to represent fake or misrepresented products.
Listing price and market alignment
Score: 10
Listing price and market alignment
"Unusually low prices are a common scam tactic, especially on high-demand electronics."
Reason: The $600 price for this graphics card is far lower than even the lowest legitimate price found ($849.99), suggesting the listing is either fraudulent or non-genuine stock.
Seller policies (returns, shipping, support)
Score: 10
Seller policies (returns, shipping, support)
"Good sellers offer at least basic returns and responsive support."
Reason: The seller refuses all returns and offers no meaningful support channels. Previous buyers report difficulties in getting refunds or even responses.
Inventory, product consistency, and fulfillment history
Score: 50
Inventory, product consistency, and fulfillment history
"No pattern of reliable fulfillment or satisfied buyer outcomes."
Reason: No stable listing or transaction history is available. Known to dropship or relay items directly from questionable sources in China/Hong Kong.
Legal compliance, risk of counterfeits & reported fraud
Score: 15
Legal compliance, risk of counterfeits & reported fraud
"Violations of eBay's terms and copyright laws are recurrent for this seller."
Reason: There are multiple direct accusations of counterfeit goods, copyright infringement, and fraud from both buyers and scam-tracking sources.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Do NOT purchase from this listing. The risk of loss or receiving a counterfeit item is extremely high.
-
2
If you have already bought from this seller, immediately document all communications and the product you receive. File a 'Significantly Not as Described' claim through eBay within 30 days.
-
3
Shop for this graphics card from Top-Rated Sellers displaying high feedback (99%+), with transparent US-based shipping and verified return policies.
-
4
Always contact the seller with detailed product questions before purchase and review their history through independent tools like Fakespot or scam forums.
-
5
Report this seller to eBay using their 'Report Item' link to help protect other buyers.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
shesbie_20 eBay listing and scam risk analysis
⤷ The listing details (feedback score, price, return policy, payment methods) are visible here.
-
Comprehensive scam and counterfeit reports for shesbie_20 (Reddit, Trustpilot, Fakespot)
⤷ Multiple buyer complaints, review manipulation analysis, and scam alerts documented for this seller from 2024–2026.
-
Market pricing for RTX 5070 Ti 16G Gaming Trio OC Plus
⤷ Market validation of legitimate pricing, showing this listing to be unusually cheap compared to known retailers.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.