Investigation Report
Generated on Feb 21, 2026
adeelnazar eBay Listing – Giorgio Armani Acqua Di Giò Absolu Eau de Parfum 4.2 oz for Men -New Pack
https://www.ebay.com/itm/227059274471Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers a 'Giorgio Armani Acqua Di Giò Absolu Eau de Parfum 4.2 oz for Men' at $42.19, dramatically lower than the $109–$160 price at established retailers. The seller, adeelnazar, has logged nearly 15,000–20,000 positive ratings (98.8% feedback on eBay) and has operated since 2018–2019. However, extensive public analysis points to high risks of counterfeit products and manipulated reviews: - 🛑 Fakespot and ReviewMeta consistently grade this seller poorly for review authenticity, flagging high rates of fake or incentivized feedback and review manipulation. - Multiple buyer complaints and external tests document counterfeit or low-quality tech goods and fragrances—sometimes even shipped without retail packaging or with mismatched serial numbers. - Multiple forums and watchdog sites cite this seller for probable knockoffs, especially for items priced well below real market value. While the seller's high feedback score initially lends credibility, major third-party tools and consistent buyer reports suggest you face a clear risk of receiving a counterfeit or misrepresented product. Proceeding with caution—or better yet, purchasing from authorized retailers—removes the risk of wasted money and disappointment.
Risk Insights
Price Way Below Market
- Listing price ($42.19) is less than 40% of the lowest reputable retailer price ($109+)
- Deep discounts for new designer fragrance almost always signal counterfeits
Pattern of Fake Reviews
- Fakespot, ReviewMeta flag large numbers of suspicious or fake reviews
- Reddit/Trustpilot reports allege review buying and deletion of negatives
Seller Sells Diverse Range
- Account sells everything from electronics to fragrances, raising authenticity risk
- Watchdog sites link this seller to tech knockoffs, not just fragrances
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Price is less than half of the next cheapest verified retailer for the same fragrance/size.
- Multiple third-party review analysis tools (Fakespot/ReviewMeta) rate this seller extremely poorly for review authenticity.
- Numerous buyer reports and watchdog sources associate this seller with counterfeits and product misrepresentation.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Product price and plausibility
Score: 10
Product price and plausibility
"Steep discounts on name-brand luxury fragrances are a textbook counterfeit indicator unless explained by verified clearance or liquidation."
Reason: The sale price ($42.19) for a full-size (4.2 oz) bottle is less than half or even a third of the lowest reliable market price (~$109+), which is implausible for authentic new designer fragrance.
Seller reputation and account history
Score: 70
Seller reputation and account history
"A long history and high feedback suggest a real account, but not necessarily reliable products given manipulation evidence."
Reason: The seller has been active since at least 2018 and has amassed 15,000–20,000 mostly positive feedback ratings (98.8%).
Review authenticity and manipulation
Score: 10
Review authenticity and manipulation
"Trust in the feedback score is undermined by evidence of artificial ratings and review gating."
Reason: Both algorithmic and human review analysis tools (Fakespot, ReviewMeta) flag high volumes of manipulated, faux, or purchased positive reviews, and Reddit users confirm review farming.
Product authenticity signals (packaging, serials, etc.)
Score: 15
Product authenticity signals (packaging, serials, etc.)
"Missing or generic packaging, failed authenticity checks, and inconsistent serials strongly indicate risk of counterfeit."
Reason: Buyer complaints, YouTube analyses, and 1–3 star eBay feedback document poor packaging and non-matching serials for similar luxury/fragrance and tech products sold by this account.
Return/refund policy
Score: 25
Return/refund policy
"Legitimate retailers almost always allow returns for new fragrances. This policy is suspicious."
Reason: Seller does not accept returns, which is extremely unusual for new luxury items—this leaves buyers with no recourse if the product is fake or misrepresented.
Consistent branding/listing details
Score: 60
Consistent branding/listing details
"Superficial correctness on eBay listings is easy to copy; deeper signals are needed to verify authenticity."
Reason: The listing uses correct product images and naming, but this alone is insufficient given price and risk factors.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Buy only from official or authorized Giorgio Armani retailers if authenticity is non-negotiable.
-
2
If you already purchased, vigorously test authenticity through the maker's check tools (e.g., verify serial numbers, packaging, batch codes).
-
3
Promptly report counterfeit suspicions to eBay using their counterfeit reporting tool.
-
4
Monitor seller feedback and third-party review sites (Fakespot, Trustpilot, Reddit).
-
5
Consider opening a dispute with your payment provider if you receive a suspected fake or the seller refuses returns.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
adeelnazar (ebay.com) fake reviews counterfeit products
⤷ Fakespot and other review analysis sites repeatedly rate adeelnazar as high-risk for inauthentic reviews. This is corroborated by Reddit forum threads and watchdog site reports.
-
Price comparison for Giorgio Armani Acqua Di Giò Absolu Eau de Parfum 4.2 oz for Men -New Pack across legitimate online sellers
⤷ Market prices at official and reputable fragrance retailers for this scent are $109–$160, compared to $42 on this listing—a major red flag.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...