Investigation Report
Generated on May 6, 2026
cartman1268 eBay Seller - 2 Mark 1901 Prussia Silver Coin Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/198319020274Why we think so?
The eBay seller cartman1268 lists a 2 Mark 1901 Prussia silver coin from Berlin and has reportedly sold over 28,000 of this item. Their feedback score is a perfect 100 (as displayed), but specific rating breakdowns or recent reviews are not provided in the evidence. No credible scam or counterfeit reports have surfaced directly linked to this seller. That said, the listing price of $20.50 is far below the typical market value ($80–$272 for coins in similar stated condition), which is unusual for legitimate numismatic sales. The seller does not accept returns, and there is no detailed product description or third-party coin authentication. While their sales volume is high, buyers should exercise caution and closely inspect the feedback/discussion history before purchase. 🔎
Risk Insights
Suspiciously Low Price for Rare Coin
- Listed at $20.50, while similar coins fetch $80–$272 on the open market.
- Potential sign of low authenticity or reproduction.
Extremely High Sales Volume
- Over 28,000 units sold of a supposed 1901 original coin.
- Unusual for rare or vintage numismatic items.
No Direct Evidence of Fraud Found
- No scam or counterfeit accusations directly tied to seller.
- Feedback is perfect but review details are sparse.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Suspiciously low list price for a coin of this type and stated condition.
- Extremely high number of sales for a supposedly rare and original vintage coin.
- No item returns accepted and no eBay authenticity guarantee available for the item.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller reputation and feedback authenticity
Score: 60
Seller reputation and feedback authenticity
"Feedback should be carefully reviewed. Use independent tools like Fakespot for further check."
Reason: The seller displays a perfect feedback score but provides almost no granularity about recent buyer experiences for this specific item. Large-scale sales of a supposedly rare coin are atypical.
Product price consistency with market norms
Score: 30
Product price consistency with market norms
"Multiple numismatic dealer and auction records set coins in similar condition at $80+."
Reason: The $20.50 sale price is far below the typical secondary market value for this type of coin in original condition, which invites skepticism.
Product imagery and description consistency
Score: 40
Product imagery and description consistency
"Absence of a third-party grader’s certification (NGC/PCGS or similar) is noteworthy."
Reason: Listing uses several images but lacks detailed description or mention of coin grading/authentication details.
Evidence of fulfillment and delivery reliability
Score: 80
Evidence of fulfillment and delivery reliability
"No negative shipping/failure to deliver reports found, but review feedback for recent complaints."
Reason: High volume of claimed sales and absence of delivery complaints imply reliable shipping for buyers who completed purchases.
Legal and counterfeit risks
Score: 55
Legal and counterfeit risks
"Always verify numismatics with expert/third-party grading, especially at below-market prices."
Reason: No direct reports of counterfeit coins from this seller were found, but price and sales volume are red flags for authenticity issues.
Business and returns policy transparency
Score: 45
Business and returns policy transparency
"Buyer protections through eBay or PayPal may still apply, but manage expectations."
Reason: No returns are accepted. While allowed by eBay, it limits buyer recourse and is uncommon among reputable coin dealers.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Ask the seller for third-party authentication or provenance documentation before purchasing.
-
2
Carefully review detailed negative feedback and any external numismatic forum reports for this seller or item.
-
3
Compare the coin's photos with reputable numismatic databases to check for authenticity and consistency.
-
4
Consider buying numismatic coins through major auction houses or certified sellers if authenticity is critical.
-
5
If you decide to proceed, use payment methods that offer buyer protection (e.g., PayPal).
Key Evidence & Citations
-
eBay listing for 2 Mark 1901 Prussia Silver Coin by cartman1268
⤷ Shows high sales volume, very low price, seller feedback, and lack of returns.
-
Market price comparison across legitimate dealers
⤷ Typical market value is $80–$272 USD depending on coin grade.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.