Ebay Investigation Report

Report generated: Jan 5, 2026

eBay Listing: Espeon VMAX (Alternate Art Secret) by seller mcliszis

https://www.ebay.com/itm/198002190725

Geo: United States (Rockville Centre, NY from item location)

Website:

Category: Ebay

Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so?

This eBay listing from seller "mcliszis" offers the Espeon VMAX (Alternate Art Secret) Pokémon card for $225. The price is at the lower end of the current ungraded market, with comparable listings and recent sales often reaching $260–$294, and some closing above $300. The seller has a perfect 100 feedback score and a history of 38 sold copies of this item. There are no known reports of counterfeit products, fake reviews, or scams tied directly to "mcliszis", and payment is protected by eBay’s Money Back Guarantee. That said, the seller does not accept returns unless the item is significantly not as described, so buyers should carefully review all images and listing details before purchasing. 🛡️

Confidence Score Our overall confidence rating for this entity based on public signals, activity, and risk checks.

91%

Risk Insights

⭐

Strong Seller Reputation

100 feedback score
No scam or counterfeit reports
Repeat sales of the item

💲

Pricing Plausibility

Price ($225) aligns with market range
Not suspiciously cheap or inflated

🛡️

Platform Level Protection

Covered by eBay Money Back Guarantee
Returns only for not-as-described cases

Category Scores

Red Flags & Warnings

Seller does not offer returns except through eBay MBG for significant discrepancies.

Detailed Checks & Insights

0-100 Scale

Seller Feedback & Identity

Score: 95

Passed

"Identity appears stable and there are no anomalies in profile or naming."

Reason: Seller shows a 100 feedback score and a pattern of repeat sales, suggesting strong reliability.

Reputation & Complaints

Score: 90

Passed

"Feedback history clean; no verified complaints."

Reason: No negative reports or scam allegations surfaced from web search nor community forums for this seller.

Listing Content & Product Consistency

Score: 90

Passed

"Multiple high-res images and standard full card information supplied."

Reason: The product listing matches the expected card for this set and release; images and description are typical for legit eBay offerings.

Price Fairness

Score: 85

Passed

"Price is not suspiciously low; recent market reference supports plausibility."

Reason: Listing is priced slightly below, but within, the typical sold range for similar cards.

Return Policies and Buyer Guarantees

Score: 93

Passed

"Limited return flexibility, but risks are managed via platform-level protection."

Reason: No standard returns, but eBay Money Back Guarantee applies for significant issues—buyers are protected in key scenarios.

Technical Authenticity Signals

Score: 85

Passed

"Images and edition specifics are congruent with known authentic versions. For 100% certainty, buyers should compare received item directly to official references."

Reason: Nothing in product images or item attributes contradicts the authenticity of the card offered.

Your Next Steps

1

Take screenshots of the listing, photos, and seller profile for your records.
2

Promptly check tracking and delivery details after purchase.
3

If the item received does not match the description, act quickly to file a claim under eBay’s Money Back Guarantee (must be within 3 days of delivery).
4

Inspect the physical card closely on receipt—compare to genuine reference images for authenticity (look for correct print patterns, texture, and holographic effects).