Investigation Report
Generated on Apr 18, 2026
Hiya Toys Skull Island Exquisite Basic Skullcrawler (Skull Devil) Action Figure by st-toys on eBay
https://www.ebay.com/itm/177920667587Why we think so?
The eBay seller "st-toys" (username: yznlcxa), based in Shanghai, China, offers the Hiya Toys Skull Island Exquisite Basic Skullcrawler action figure. This seller has a strong overall feedback score of 99.3% and a diverse inventory of collectible action figures, with over 1,000 items listed and 147 units of this Skullcrawler figure sold. However, the listed price ($98.01 plus $39.99 shipping) is significantly higher than average retail prices for this product ($50–$53 from major retailers). There are no clear signs of counterfeit or manipulation specific to 'st-toys', but industry reports warn that eBay's review system can be abused, potentially obscuring issues with rating accuracy or product authenticity. Use caution, compare prices, and examine feedback details before purchasing high-value or collectible toys from overseas sellers.
Risk Insights
High Seller Rating, But Price Markup 🚩
- 99.3% feedback and many sales signal reliability.
- Item listed at $98.01 (+$39.99 shipping) vs. official $51.00 price.
- High-end collectibles frequently targeted by counterfeiters on eBay.
eBay Toys Collectibles—Systemic Risks
- eBay reviews and ratings often manipulated across unrelated products.
- No direct complaints about 'st-toys' found, but due diligence is needed.
- Price-check and request clear, detailed photos before ordering.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Significant price markup compared to retail and official sources for the same product.
- General risk of review manipulation and counterfeit goods endemic to eBay's collectible toys sector.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and account history
Score: 85
Seller identity and account history
"This suggests a stable, ongoing business presence with generally positive buyer experiences."
Reason: Seller yznlcxa (st-toys) is an established eBay store with 99.3% feedback and a large catalog of collectible items.
Reputation and feedback integrity
Score: 72
Reputation and feedback integrity
"Scrutiny of individual feedback is needed to ensure reliability on high-value purchases."
Reason: While their feedback is strong, eBay’s platform is prone to review manipulation and fake ratings in the collectibles niche.
Product authenticity and consistency
Score: 60
Product authenticity and consistency
"Request additional verification if authenticity is critical for your purchase."
Reason: No direct evidence of counterfeiting in this listing, but significant price markup and lack of unique product details/photos raise caution.
Legal and commercial legitimacy
Score: 70
Legal and commercial legitimacy
"No obvious legal or policy breaches based on listing data."
Reason: Operating as an established eBay store, following standard returns and payment policies.
Marketplace trust and risk
Score: 60
Marketplace trust and risk
"Buying high-value collectibles from overseas sellers on eBay always carries risk. Protect yourself using buyer protection and by scrutinizing the listing and seller."
Reason: eBay’s sector for collectibles is widely documented to harbor counterfeits, price gouging, and unreliable review systems.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Compare this item’s price with the official Hiya Toys website or U.S. specialty retailers—expect to pay around $50–$53 new for this figure.
-
2
Carefully review detailed seller feedback and look for reports mentioning authenticity or item condition.
-
3
Request additional photos or packaging details to help verify authenticity, especially for expensive, collectible toys.
-
4
If you decide to purchase, use a payment method with buyer protection (like PayPal) and save all order documentation.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Which?—eBay customer reviews: hundreds of scams and fake review issues
⤷ Details widespread fake review and counterfeit product risks on eBay, though not directly implicating 'st-toys'.
-
Official Hiya Toys Store — Skullcrawler Product Page
⤷ Shows authentic product price at $51.00, highlighting the steep markup on the eBay listing.
-
Midtown Comics — Hiya Toys Kong Skull Island Skullcrawler Figure
⤷ Corroborates the typical retail price ($52.99) for this figure at reputable U.S. retailer.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.