Ebay Investigation Report

Report generated: Dec 14, 2025

eBay Listing: 1964-65 Topps #110 GLENN HALL All-Star by aholmes.pgss

https://www.ebay.ca/itm/176134672716

Geo: Canada

Website:

Category: Ebay

Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so?

This eBay listing offers a 1964-65 Topps #110 Glenn Hall All-Star hockey card from seller aholmes.pgss, based in Ottawa, Canada. The card is listed as "Ungraded - Excellent" and is priced at C$140 with over 288 units sold, suggesting an established sales history. The seller has a perfect feedback score of 100, but their public profile lacks additional detail like store description or volume statistics. There is no public online evidence of scam reports, counterfeit complaints, or fake review accusations against this seller. The sale price fits within recent market norms for this type and condition of card. The listing does not accept returns, but purchases are protected by eBay’s Money Back Guarantee if the card is not as described or fails authenticity checks. Buyers should compare photos to graded examples for peace of mind and buy only through eBay’s checkout. No major red flags are present, though standard eBay caution (e.g., inspecting images, retaining all correspondence, and avoiding off-platform communication) applies.

Confidence Score Our overall confidence rating for this entity based on public signals, activity, and risk checks.

82%

Risk Insights

📈

Strong Sales History

288 units sold for this card on the listing.
Perfect 100 feedback score for seller.

🛡️

No Public Complaints

No scam or counterfeit reports for seller.
No fake review allegations found in search.

💰

Market-Consistent Price

Listing price aligns with recent authentic sales.
No 'too good to be true' red flags.

🔒

Platform Protections Apply

eBay Money Back Guarantee covers non-delivery and not as described.
Pay directly through eBay checkout for full protection.

Category Scores

Red Flags & Warnings

Seller does not accept returns, which reduces flexibility for remorse returns, though this is common for collectibles and is offset by eBay's buyer protections.

Detailed Checks & Insights

0-100 Scale

Seller profile age, sales volume, and feedback

Score: 88

Passed

"The public profile lacks some details, such as store banner and long-term sales stats, but the individual listing’s sales and strong buyer feedback compensate for this."

Reason: The seller has sold hundreds of this card and maintains a perfect feedback score, supporting reliability.

Transparency and product authenticity signals

Score: 82

Passed

"Images can be compared to authenticated cards for further confidence, though no full grading is listed."

Reason: Multiple clear photos show the actual card; description matches the product. No evidence of fake stock photos or vague listings.

Review and scam complaint checks

Score: 84

Passed

"A broader search turned up no suspicious activity or active scam warnings."

Reason: Web and forum scans reveal no scam, counterfeit, or review manipulation allegations involving the seller.

Product price and detail consistency with market norms

Score: 87

Passed

"Recent sales for similar ungraded to PSA 4 graded cards range from about $90 to $220 depending on condition, supporting validity."

Reason: The C$140 price is within recent sold price ranges for legitimate, ungraded examples of this card.

Return, fulfillment, and payment policies

Score: 80

Passed

"Buyers are protected against fraud, damage, or SNAD (significantly not as described); returns for remorse are not accepted."

Reason: Although the seller offers no returns, eBay's Money Back Guarantee covers cases of items not as described. Accepted payment and fulfillment methods are standard.

Counterfeit or manipulation red flags

Score: 84

Passed

"Buyers should still conduct their own visual check for vintage card authenticity signs, especially with collectible sports cards."

Reason: No counterfeit indicators in the listing. The product is presented with original images, and all details match expected parameters.

Your Next Steps

1

Review recent buyer feedback for more transaction context (use the listing's feedback page link).
2

Compare all images of the card to graded (authenticated) examples online to look for discrepancies.
3

Pay only through eBay’s checkout to ensure Money Back Guarantee coverage, and never send payment outside of eBay channels.
4

If the item arrives and differs from the listing description or is suspected fake, begin a return or escalation via eBay’s system within 30 days.