Investigation Report
Generated on Mar 7, 2026
Afnan Men's Supremacy Collector's Edition EDP Spray 3.4 oz Fragrances by and714289
https://www.ebay.com/itm/168196291812Why we think so?
This eBay listing for Afnan Men's Supremacy Collector's Edition (EDP Spray, 3.4oz) is offered by the seller "and714289". The seller has a perfect feedback score (100), over 90 sales for this item, and a store based in Rancho Cucamonga, CA. They manage a diverse inventory and have 96 active listings—mostly fragrances and general consumer goods. The pricing ($28.59) is well below the typical prices from major online retailers like Walmart ($36.69) and the official Afnan store ($50), which could attract bargain hunters. The listing is for a new, sealed fragrance, shows multiple, high-quality images, and includes product specifics. However, the seller does not accept returns, which is stricter than most large fragrance retailers who typically offer at least a basic return policy. While there’s no direct evidence of counterfeit or fake review activity, the seller is not a Top Rated Seller nor offers eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee. This moderately increases risk, especially given the lower-than-market price. Still, the overall feedback history and item volume show signs of legitimate, ongoing business activity. 🛍️
Risk Insights
Legitimate Seller, but Lower Price = Higher Risk
- Price is noticeably below official retail for this brand.
- No signs of fake reviews or scam history found through public research.
- No returns accepted may create friction if unhappy with purchase.
Active Store and Transaction Record
- Over 90 sales for this fragrance alone.
- 100% feedback with a long, varied product list points to ongoing legitimate business.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Price is well below official and mainstream retail for the same product, which can be a hallmark of grey market, overstock, or counterfeit goods.
- No returns accepted by seller, which limits recourse if you are unhappy with your purchase.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller account legitimacy
Score: 90
Seller account legitimacy
""
Reason: The and714289 account has a perfect 100 feedback score and an active, varied inventory. Multiple items sold, not a new account.
Product authenticity risk
Score: 60
Product authenticity risk
""
Reason: Fragrances are a high-risk category for counterfeits, and the price is abnormally low vs official retail. Still, there are no negative reviews or specific complaints about fake goods linked to this seller.
Listing quality and product detail
Score: 80
Listing quality and product detail
""
Reason: Listing provides clear photos, accurate product specifications, and claims to sell a new/sealed box. No major red flags in content.
Transactions and buyer reviews
Score: 75
Transactions and buyer reviews
""
Reason: Over 90 sales on this listing with a strong rating record, indicating real delivery of product. The feedback summary is positive.
Return/refund policy
Score: 55
Return/refund policy
""
Reason: Seller does not accept returns, so you have only eBay's Money Back Guarantee if the product is not as described.
Counterfeit, scam, or manipulation signals
Score: 75
Counterfeit, scam, or manipulation signals
""
Reason: No signs of review manipulation, fake feedback, or publicly reported scams linked to seller found in external or eBay search.
Your Next Steps
-
1
If you buy, pay only through eBay/PayPal checkout—never off-platform.
-
2
Carefully check packaging and serial numbers on arrival; compare to official Afnan product photos.
-
3
If the item appears inauthentic or something seems off, initiate an eBay Money Back Guarantee claim immediately.
-
4
Consider spending slightly more at a retailer with returns and authenticity safeguards if you want maximum protection.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Afnan Men's Supremacy Collector's Edition official pricing and market comparison
⤷ The product is $50 direct from the brand, $36–$40 on major US retailers, so a $28.59 offer is unusually low.
-
Seller eBay Profile: and714289
⤷ Profile confirms 100 feedback score and diverse, legitimate-seeming product inventory.
-
eBay listing: No returns accepted
⤷ No-return policy noted under listing details.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.