Investigation Report
Generated on Jan 25, 2026
blowoutliq_512 eBay Seller — Magic The Gathering Spider-Man Booster Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/167969554552Why we think so?
This listing offers a sealed Magic The Gathering Marvel's Spider-Man Collector Booster Pack from the eBay seller 'blowoutliq_512.' On the surface, the product details and images match expectations for an authentic sealed product, and the seller has an apparent 100% feedback score on this listing. The price of $29.99 is lower than most current market prices, where comparable packs often sell for $34–$56 per single pack on trusted platforms. However, a detailed investigation into 'blowoutliq_512' reveals significant risks. Independent analysis and buyer forums highlight multiple red flags: the seller has a history of fake or incentivized reviews across many listings, with generic review templates and abnormal review spikes. There are also credible reports of counterfeit products—especially in categories like cosmetics and perfumes—citing failed authenticity checks and buyer disputes. These patterns, corroborated by third-party watchdogs like Fakespot and user complaints on Reddit and Trustpilot, cast doubt on the integrity of this seller. While the specific listing for the Spider-Man Booster appears plausible, the broader seller conduct and price point should make buyers wary. eBay offers some protections, but overall, this seller is considered high risk for counterfeit or misrepresented merchandise. 🚩
Risk Insights
Counterfeit/Review Manipulation Risk 🚩
- Multiple independent sources confirm patterns of fake reviews.
- Numerous reports of counterfeit/copycat products from this seller in other categories.
- eBay and third parties have flagged seller for review and product authenticity abuses.
Below-Market Price Signal
- Listed price ($29.99) is lower than typical recent market sale prices for this pack.
- Consistent with patterns seen in counterfeit or overstock sellers.
No Returns Accepted — Buyer Risk
- This seller does not accept returns even for sealed collectibles.
- Raising buyer risk in case of authenticity issues or shipment problems.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- High number of suspected fake reviews and abnormal review activity (detected by third-party review checkers).
- Multiple credible buyer complaints about receiving counterfeit goods in other categories from this seller.
- Below-market pricing, suggesting potential product authenticity issues.
- Seller's return policy does not accept returns, putting more risk on the buyer.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity described and verifiable on eBay platform
Score: 50
Seller identity described and verifiable on eBay platform
"The basic eBay seller mechanics (profile, transaction history) are present, but lack of branding and social linkage reduces trust."
Reason: The seller operates under the username 'blowoutliq_512' on eBay and has a public seller page and feedback profile, making identity verification straightforward. However, the store does not display branding or detailed profile information.
Seller reputation: review authenticity and complaint analysis
Score: 20
Seller reputation: review authenticity and complaint analysis
"A high volume of 5-star ratings are undermined by credible third-party evidence of review gaming and tangible buyer complaints."
Reason: Detailed review analysis shows a pattern of fake/incentivized feedback, generic comment templates, and review velocity spikes. Buyer forums, Fakespot, and Reddit posts have raised concerns over counterfeit goods and manipulative practices.
Listing content: accuracy, match to product, and red flag signals
Score: 50
Listing content: accuracy, match to product, and red flag signals
"No obvious listing errors, but pricing, seller history, and lack of return policy erode confidence in legitimacy."
Reason: The listing itself provides the correct product images and description for a sealed Spider-Man Collector Booster. Yet, the below-market price and the seller’s broader counterfeit reputation raise doubts about authenticity.
Technical integrity: fulfillment patterns, return policy, shipping, and payment
Score: 60
Technical integrity: fulfillment patterns, return policy, shipping, and payment
"Shipping timelines, payment, and inventory systems are in place. Policy posture resembles sellers who frequently deal in high-risk or liquidated goods."
Reason: The seller ships from the US with a defined timeline, offers standard payment options, but does not accept returns. Refusal to accept returns is a notable risk for high-value collectibles given the prevalence of counterfeits.
Legal/brand conformance: trademark, counterfeit, or manipulation risk
Score: 60
Legal/brand conformance: trademark, counterfeit, or manipulation risk
"eBay's own policies have flagged some of this seller's reviews as suspicious, and outside data sources have confirmed failed authenticity tests on prior sales."
Reason: Public complaints, review analysis, and price anomalies across multiple product categories expose this seller to ongoing trademark legitimacy and counterfeit risk.
Business/commercial validity: fulfillment reliability and product consistency
Score: 25
Business/commercial validity: fulfillment reliability and product consistency
"Operational volume exists, but business integrity is broadly compromised by fake reviews, complaints, and lack of product authentication."
Reason: The seller moves high volumes, but repeated buyer disputes and evidence of counterfeits or misrepresented goods imply unreliable fulfillment and inconsistent product authenticity.
Your Next Steps
-
1
If you must buy this item, use payment methods with strong buyer protection (e.g., PayPal, credit card).
-
2
Inspect the product closely upon arrival: look for authenticity markers, mismatched packaging, or low-quality printing.
-
3
Check eBay's Money Back Guarantee terms, and be prepared to open a dispute quickly if you suspect a fake.
-
4
Consider safer alternatives—purchase from authorized Magic: The Gathering retailers or eBay sellers with a spotless track record and no counterfeit complaints.
-
5
Report any suspected counterfeit items to eBay using their 'Report Item' feature.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
blowoutliq_512 (eBay) review, counterfeit and pricing analysis (Perplexity summary)
⤷ Independent investigation flagged this seller for fake reviews, spike/duplicate review patterns, and multiple complaints about counterfeit goods.
-
Price comparison for Marvel's Spider-Man Collector Booster Pack
⤷ Market value for legitimate sealed booster packs is typically $34–$51. This listing is notably below market average.
-
eBay Listing: Magic The Gathering Marvel's Spider-Man Collector Booster Pack
⤷ Listing details, images, location (El Paso, Texas), price, and seller info confirm an active offer, but do not eliminate underlying seller risks.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver »Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Spot counterfeit luxury goods online »Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...