Investigation Report
Generated on Mar 27, 2026
eBay Listing: LE SSERAFIM OFFICIAL ANTIFRAGILE GOODS INSTANT POLAROID PHOTOCARD by Seller bw10463407
https://www.ebay.com/itm/167814483635Why we think so?
This eBay listing offers 'LE SSERAFIM OFFICIAL ANTIFRAGILE GOODS INSTANT POLAROID PHOTOCARD' from seller bw10463407 at $24.99. The seller has a long history on eBay (over 14,000 reported sales and 99.8% feedback), but several third-party reports specifically identify them as a seller of unofficial or counterfeit K-pop signed memorabilia. The listing description, available options, and the volume of sales do not provide clear authenticity statements, and the item is notably higher priced than similar listings on other platforms (which range $8–$18). While the high sales count and feedback may inspire confidence, persistent concerns over authenticity and public warnings cannot be ignored—especially since the seller is specifically listed on cautionary collector blogs and counterfeiting exposés. If you value genuine merchandise or collectibles, proceed with caution and verify before purchasing. 🛑
Risk Insights
Seller Previously Flagged for Fakes
- Listed as 'non-trustworthy' by collector blog and user comments.
- Specific complaints point to unofficial K-pop signed merchandise.
Strong eBay Feedback – But Proceed Carefully
- Over 14,000 items sold, 99.8% positive feedback.
- High volume can sometimes mask authenticity issues in collectibles.
Price Higher Than Market
- Item costs $24.99 vs. $8-$18 on official and top resell sites.
- No extra value or authenticity claim provided to justify markup.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Seller is listed as 'NON-TRUSTWORTHY' on international K-pop collector blogs, referenced for fakes since at least 2016.
- Listing does not promise authenticity or mention official status; describes product using generic or ambiguous terms.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and reputation
Score: 40
Seller identity and reputation
"Seller's large volume and feedback percentage do not outweigh multiple historic warnings on collectible blogs and forums."
Reason: Seller is repeatedly flagged by community and collector sources with evidence of selling unofficial or replica K-pop memorabilia.
Product authenticity and description consistency
Score: 45
Product authenticity and description consistency
"Other sellers offer similar items for significantly less, and this listing’s description lacks detail or warranty of authenticity."
Reason: No explicit statement of official/authentic status. Blog sources, price comparison, and ambiguous item description all raise doubts.
Fulfillment and transaction transparency
Score: 75
Fulfillment and transaction transparency
"eBay’s policies can safeguard buyers from some fraud, but response depends on accurate dispute reporting."
Reason: 14,000+ sold with standard eBay payment methods and buyer protection are in place.
Legal compliance and business legitimacy
Score: 35
Legal compliance and business legitimacy
"Persisting reports since at least 2016 with no meaningful change suggests unwillingness or inability to fully comply with legitimate goods standards."
Reason: Selling unofficial/counterfeit goods violates eBay policies and potentially copyright laws, as documented in collector reports.
Product reviews and buyer feedback scrutiny
Score: 50
Product reviews and buyer feedback scrutiny
"Official product review counts are absent; no indication of systematic review manipulation detected, but the risk exists given the item type."
Reason: No direct evidence of fake reviews, but eBay feedback can be misleadingly high even for sellers of counterfeits.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Ask the seller for authentication details: request proof of purchase or official documentation.
-
2
Check the listing and previous buyer feedback for key phrases like 'unofficial', 'replica', or comments about authenticity.
-
3
Compare pricing and images with official sources or respected reseller platforms.
-
4
If you have already purchased, use eBay’s Money Back Guarantee to report suspected counterfeits and request a refund.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Cafarnaum Box: List of Sellers Selling (and Faking) Signed Items
⤷ Blog documents user reports—bw10463407 is named among sellers with counterfeit/unofficial K-pop goods and 'fake signatures'.
-
eBay Listing: LE SSERAFIM Official Photocard Details
⤷ 14,000+ sold but listing omits authentication details and there is no clear provenance.
-
eBay Counterfeit Item Safety Centre
⤷ eBay cautions about counterfeits and outlines refund policy.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.