Investigation Report
Generated on Mar 11, 2026
homerefresh (eBay seller of KICHLER Northland 16.75 in. 1-Light Black Outdoor Hardwired Barn Sconce)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/147070001751Why we think so?
The eBay seller 'homerefresh' is offering a KICHLER Northland outdoor barn sconce for $70, which is dramatically lower than typical retail prices (Walmart listed at $269.99, Destination Lighting at $389.99). While the listing shows the product as 'new' and features multiple images, there are notable legitimacy gaps. The seller's profile lacks visible feedback and does not share standard seller metrics like sold history, feedback ratings, or items sold. The listing notes 8 units sold and 10 available, yet no buyer feedback details are shown for these transactions, and the seller does not accept returns. There are no reports or reviews accusing 'homerefresh' of scams or counterfeit products, but the extremely low price compared to all verified retailers raises a significant red flag for potential counterfeit or bait-and-switch tactics. If you choose to proceed, use PayPal or another protected payment method for maximum buyer security, and scrutinize the listing details and images carefully. It's safer to pay more with a well-established retailer or eBay seller with a strong, public track record. 🛑
Risk Insights
Price Impossibly Low for Genuine Product
- Product is listed at $70 versus $269.99+ at reputable retailers.
- Extreme price drops without explanation are a primary counterfeit indicator.
- No mention of clearance, open-box, or previous use.
No Seller Feedback or Reputation Data Available
- eBay profile for 'homerefresh' has no public feedback.
- Lack of transaction transparency and ratings creates additional risk.
No Known Scam Reports Found
- No direct accusations of fraud or counterfeiting related to 'homerefresh'.
- Listing and seller absent from scam watchlists.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Extraordinarily low sale price compared to market value.
- Seller has no current feedback or activity data available, raising questions about authenticity and track record.
- No seller returns accepted, which limits recourse in the event of issues with product authenticity.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity traceable and consistent
Score: 35
Seller identity traceable and consistent
"No seller store information, logo, or feedback rating is visible on the current eBay and seller page snapshots."
Reason: The seller 'homerefresh' does not show a feedback history or public identity details, making it hard to verify who is behind the account.
Seller has substantial, authentic reputation on target platform
Score: 25
Seller has substantial, authentic reputation on target platform
"This seller's eBay storefront and profile show no recent activity, ratings, or feedback from buyers."
Reason: No visible feedback, sales history, or satisfaction rate for the seller on eBay.
Product listing details are consistent with official specifications
Score: 65
Product listing details are consistent with official specifications
"Visual details, brand, and model names are consistent with those found at big-box retailers."
Reason: The product images, model name, and basic specs appear to match the original Kichler lighting product.
Product pricing is reasonable compared to legitimate outlets
Score: 10
Product pricing is reasonable compared to legitimate outlets
"Big discounts can be legitimate for clearance or open-box, but here there is no reason provided and no returns policy."
Reason: The $70 eBay listing is vastly lower than the next lowest trusted retailer ($269.99 at Walmart). Such a large discount is suspicious.
Clear fulfillment information and expected delivery
Score: 60
Clear fulfillment information and expected delivery
"Most major platforms show tracking status or more detailed arrival estimates; this listing does not."
Reason: The location is stated (Diamond Bar, CA), and the item condition is marked 'new', but the delivery date is vague.
Buyer satisfaction and feedback patterns are transparent
Score: 20
Buyer satisfaction and feedback patterns are transparent
"A complete lack of visible buyer feedback for recent sales limits visibility into real buyer experience."
Reason: There are no reviews, ratings, or buyer comments available for this item or seller.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Compare the listing details and photos closely to those from official retailers (Walmart, Destination Lighting) to spot inconsistencies.
-
2
Only use PayPal or a credit card for payment to enable buyer protection if something goes wrong.
-
3
Check if eBay Buyer Protection applies even if the seller does not accept returns, especially for items described as 'not as advertised'.
-
4
If in doubt, consider purchasing from a seller with a substantial rating and public transaction history, even if the price is higher.
-
5
Document all communications and transaction information in case you need to open a dispute.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
ebay.com listing (homerefresh, KICHLER Northland Sconce)
⤷ Listing information shows low price, no returns, and absent feedback data.
-
Price comparison: Walmart, Destination Lighting, Home Depot
⤷ Verifies that the legitimate price is several times higher than the eBay listing.
-
General red flags for eBay sellers (community discussion)
⤷ Outlines typical eBay scam signals; seller 'homerefresh' does not show up as specifically flagged, but lack of feedback and price issues align with warning signs.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.