Investigation Report

Big Mill Trading (ebay seller ID: valhallavintageresale) has an extensive eBay history and diverse inventory, currently offering the "HyVee Exclusive Diecast Indycar Series Number 45 Black Variant Greenlight"—a collectible diecast car. The seller’s store features hundreds of varied items, and the business appears to be based in Gambier, Ohio. Key strengths for legitimacy include a 99.3% positive feedback score and a record of 1,878 units sold for this specific item, both strong signals of real, successful transactions. There are no major scam reports, fake review accusations, or allegations of counterfeit related directly to Big Mill Trading. Shipping is free, returns are available for 30 days (buyer covers return shipping), and payments are processed via trusted methods such as PayPal, Google Pay, Venmo, and cards, all of which offer buyer protections. Notably, the listed item is priced at $42, which is considerably above the typical ~$13–$16 price listed at legitimate online competitors, and much higher than documented in-store clearances ($2 at HyVee stores). This price premium is not illegal or fraudulent, but buyers should be aware of cheaper alternatives. Still, nothing in the listing, sales history, nor seller reputation points to scam risk or bad-faith trading.