Investigation Report
Generated on Mar 9, 2026
STAR PLATINUM - Trading card store (eBay seller: koichisstore)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/136987756363Why we think so?
STAR PLATINUM - Trading card store is an established eBay seller based in Japan, specializing in trading cards like the "Enel L OP05-098 Japanese ONE PIECE Card Promo BASE SHOP - NM". The listing shows a very high sales volume (over 12,800 sold) and a positive feedback score of 99.3%, which are strong signals of reliability. Pricing for the card is higher than the typical market rate for ungraded copies, yet the seller offers global shipping and a 60-day return policy, absorbing return shipping costs—something rare among overseas trading card sellers. There are no credible reports or complaints online about counterfeit cards or fake reviews linked to this seller. Still, interested buyers should be aware that the item is ungraded and the substantially higher price compared to market averages means it may be aimed at collectors willing to pay for speed or reliability. 🛡️
Risk Insights
Trusted seller with extensive sales history
- Over 12,800 units of this card sold.
- Seller has 99.3% positive feedback.
- Public store identity and global presence.
No red flags for fraud or counterfeiting
- No credible complaints about counterfeits or fake reviews found.
- Seller offers strong buyer protections including 60-day returns.
High price versus market average
- Card listed at $24.69 versus ~$0.50 market value for ungraded NM copies.
- Premium may reflect shipping, reliability, or brand more than item rarity.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- The listing price ($24.69 plus shipping) is significantly above the typical ungraded NM market price (about $0.50, according to PriceCharting), which may reflect a collector or international shipping premium rather than card scarcity.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller identity and longevity
Score: 93
Seller identity and longevity
"The username and store identity are stable and publicly visible, and the seller has conducted over ten thousand transactions on this single card listing."
Reason: STAR PLATINUM (koichisstore) is a long-running, highly rated eBay store with clear business identification and a consistent profile.
Reputation and complaint check
Score: 90
Reputation and complaint check
"PriceCharting and YouTube reviewers have not raised concerns about fakes from STAR PLATINUM. Independent web search confirmed absence of widespread complaints."
Reason: No credible reports online of fraud, counterfeit cards, or large-scale negative buyer experiences connected to this seller.
Product consistency and accuracy
Score: 84
Product consistency and accuracy
"The listing displays genuine photography and lists all relevant card details (set, number, language, rarity, etc.). No misrepresentation visible."
Reason: Listing contains multiple, high-quality images and detailed product metadata. High sales numbers indicate the item is delivered as expected.
Fulfillment patterns and buyer protections
Score: 90
Fulfillment patterns and buyer protections
"Buyer risk is minimized through eBay's refund policies and the seller's 60-day returns with seller-paid shipping."
Reason: Seller offers worldwide shipping, a lengthy return period, and accepts trusted payment methods (PayPal, cards), bettering industry standards.
Pricing & commercial validity
Score: 35
Pricing & commercial validity
"Price difference may reflect shipping from Japan, seller reputation, or a premium for international collectors rather than card rarity or grade."
Reason: Listing price is much higher than typical ungraded market value for this card, not clearly justified by scarcity or grading.
Legal and regulatory compliance
Score: 92
Legal and regulatory compliance
"All business activity is traceable to the eBay store and follows Japanese and eBay marketplace standards."
Reason: No evidence of policy violations, intellectual property infringement, or regulatory risks. The seller operates openly and transparently within eBay's framework.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Double-check the card's images and description to ensure they match expectations and are not stock photos.
-
2
Compare the listing price to recent sold prices for this card in NM (Near Mint) condition on platforms like PriceCharting, TCGPlayer, and eBay for maximum value.
-
3
On receipt, review card condition personally and use third-party grading or authenticity checks if authenticity is critical to you.
-
4
Retain all purchase records and communicate via eBay Messages for full buyer protection.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Enel L OP05-098 Japanese ONE PIECE Card Promo BASE SHOP - NM | eBay listing
⤷ Confirmed seller reputation, item details, pricing, feedback, and return policies.
-
Counterfeit/Fake review check and price comparisons for STAR PLATINUM - Trading card store
⤷ No credible complaints about fakes or review abuse; price point for ungraded cards much lower than listing price.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.