Investigation Report
Generated on Mar 19, 2026
nonamecollectibles (eBay seller) – Pokemon Prismatic Evolutions Booster Bundle + Surprise Box Bundle Listing
https://www.ebay.com/itm/127755727559Why we think so?
The eBay listing for the "Pokemon Prismatic Evolutions Booster Bundle + Surprise Box Bundle (Sam's Club)" is sold by nonamecollectibles, a seller based in Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. They have achieved a 99.9% positive feedback score, with nearly 800 units of this specific product sold. While the listing appears well-presented and there are no direct allegations of fraud or counterfeiting against this seller, there are a few reasons for caution. The listed price of $109.99 is significantly higher than the typical market price for similar products, which ranges from about $60 to $71 for a sealed booster bundle on reputable sites like TCGPlayer and PriceCharting. Additionally, the "Surprise Box Bundle" component and the combined Sam's Club bundle do not appear in official listings or recent sales data from recognized retailers, raising questions about the bundle composition and value. The seller does not accept returns beyond the eBay Money Back Guarantee, so buyers should carefully review all details and consider if the higher price and bundling represent fair value. No evidence was found of fake reviews or direct counterfeit allegations targeting nonamecollectibles, but expert guidance in the collectibles space consistently warns that even high-feedback eBay sellers are not guaranteed to provide authentic goods. Use eBay's Money Back Guarantee protection and compare market prices to make an informed purchase decision.
Risk Insights
High price vs market
- Listing is $109.99, while verified market prices are $60–$71 for similar bundles.
- No clear reason for markup such as exclusive or rare contents.
Bundle contents unclear
- No evidence the 'Surprise Box Bundle (Sam's Club)' is a real, official retail pack.
- Unclear what extra value is provided in the bundle.
Seller is high volume, high feedback
- Almost 800 units sold with 99.9% positive feedback.
- But feedback alone does not guarantee authenticity of collectible items.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- The product bundle description does not match any verifiable offering from Sam's Club or major retailers, leaving product contents ambiguous.
- Listing price is around 50–80% higher than the average market value for similar sealed bundles without clear justification.
- No-returns policy increases risk, especially with ambiguous product makeup for a high-value collectible.
Detailed Checks & Insights
0-100 Scale
Seller Identification and Longevity
Score: 85
Seller Identification and Longevity
"long history of successful transactions, but collectibles experts caution that high feedback does not prove product authenticity"
Reason: Seller is established on eBay, based in the US, with a 99.9% positive feedback score and many sales.
Seller Reputation and Review Authenticity
Score: 65
Seller Reputation and Review Authenticity
"The collectibles space warns about feedback being weak for vetting authenticity; no independent third-party reviews noted."
Reason: No complaints or scam allegations found, but high feedback alone is not evidence of genuine collectibles authenticity.
Product and Listing Content Consistency
Score: 60
Product and Listing Content Consistency
"Lack of clarity about bundle specifics and origin; could be a repack or value unclear."
Reason: Product described as a Sam's Club-exclusive bundle with 'Surprise Box,' but no matching products found from Sam's Club or mainstream sites.
Fulfillment Patterns and Inventory
Score: 65
Fulfillment Patterns and Inventory
"Quantity available (3 currently), many sold, and typical eBay fulfillment patterns."
Reason: Almost 800 units sold and still available; high volume and fast sales suggest reliable fulfillment track record.
Pricing and Counterfeit/Product Manipulation Risk
Score: 55
Pricing and Counterfeit/Product Manipulation Risk
"No matching bundle at Sam's Club or major outlets; price is far over typical retail or resale."
Reason: Price is considerably higher than the retail or secondary market average for comparable bundles, suggesting possible markup that does not match product verifiability.
Legal and Consumer Protection Compliance
Score: 70
Legal and Consumer Protection Compliance
"Buyers can claim protection within 3 days after delivery if items do not match description."
Reason: Listing is covered by eBay's Money Back Guarantee for description mismatches but is subject to a strict no-returns policy.
Your Next Steps
-
1
Compare the product offering to recent market prices for similar sealed Pokemon Prismatic Evolutions bundles.
-
2
If authenticity or value is essential, request additional clarity from the seller about the 'Surprise Box' component contents and Sam's Club sourcing.
-
3
Consider buying only if you are comfortable with the no-returns policy and rely on eBay's Money Back Guarantee if the item is significantly not as described.
-
4
When possible, use eBay's Authenticity Guarantee or purchase from recognized TCG retailers for rare or high-value items.
Key Evidence & Citations
-
Market price comparison and risk analysis of eBay collectibles
⤷ Market prices for similar bundles ($60–$71); no official matches for this 'Sam's Club' combo.
-
Seller profile and product listing details
⤷ Feedback, item details, seller policies, sales history, and available quantity.
🕵🏻 Keep vetting
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
👤 Find any Person »Find and investigate any person / online identity on 7 social media platforms.
📞 Investigate Phone No. »Attribute a phone number to real-world identities, linked online accounts, carrier data, emails, etc.