Amazon Due Diligence
Report for YY Wireless
Ā Why we think so?Ā
š© YY Wireless (also known as Bayshine Trading Inc) operates a high-volume Amazon storefront, specializing in refurbished and renewed electronics, including the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 Pro 45mm LTE. While the sellerās Amazon metrics show robust salesāover 2,000 Amazon reviews in the past year and an average star rating of 4.5āitās important to weigh these figures against a disturbing pattern reported outside Amazon: repeated allegations of scams, return/refund manipulation, false advertising, and sale of carrier-locked or non-authentic devices. Notably, Trustpilot and BBB show many complaints citing items not as advertised, questionable return denials, and inconsistent customer service. Pricing for the featured watch is sharply lower than Samsungās official store, raising both deal appeal and suspicion. Amazonās fulfillment and return policy provide some buyer protection, but purchasing from YY Wireless should be approached with caution due to credible historic risks.
Risk Insights
High Complaint Volume
- Trustpilot and BBB list many recurring complaints involving scams and misrepresentation.
- Pattern includes return denials despite tracking, locked phones mis-sold as unlocked.
Amazon Protections Apply
- Fulfilled by Amazon includes A-Z Guarantee and Amazon return handling.
- Act quickly if anything is wrongāAmazonās processes are time-limited.
Suspiciously Low Pricing
- Offered price is less than half manufacturer list price for the model.
- Great for bargains, but often a warning sign for gray-market or non-genuine goods.
Contradictory Signals
The disconnect between Amazon-only reviews and off-Amazon complaints suggests ratings may not reveal the full customer risk.
Signal A: Amazon shows high seller rating and sales volume.
Signal B: Trustpilot/BBB show high risk of scams and buyer loss.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
- Documented cases of product misrepresentation, especially unlocked status and device condition.
- Numerous credible reports of return/refund denials and unresponsive service (BBB, Trustpilot).
š Detailed Checks & Analysis
Amazon product details and pricing are consistent with legitimate listings.
Score: 60/100
Amazon product details and pricing are consistent with legitimate listings.
"Drastic price gap to authorized sellers raises concern; photos and specs are typical, but this is often the case for counterfeit or gray-market items too."
Reason: Price is abnormally low versus official sources; key specs and details match Samsung documentation, but condition (brand new vs renewed) and authenticity may not be guaranteed.
Seller profile transparency, history, and verified business metrics.
Score: 40/100
Seller profile transparency, history, and verified business metrics.
"Over 13,500 Amazon reviews, 4.5 average in past year, but many negative experiences off-platform and use of alternate business names."
Reason: Seller operates under multiple names, with a known record of serious complaints on BBB and Trustpilot, including for misrepresentation and denied returns.
Review authenticity and product feedback.
Score: 35/100
Review authenticity and product feedback.
"Amazon electronics is a category with known review fraud, and external reviews show consumers report different realities than Amazonās ratings suggest."
Reason: Although Amazon reviews are mostly positive and verified, volume and product type (refurbished electronics) make manipulation plausible. Off-Amazon complaints outweigh on-platform positives.
Product consistency, model identification, and counterfeit signals.
Score: 55/100
Product consistency, model identification, and counterfeit signals.
"Specs and visuals are correct, but low price and seller track record mean risk of gray-market or altered goods (e.g., carrier-locked or not truly new)."
Reason: Listing details match real Samsung Watch 5 Pro specs, yet sellerās history and price undercut suggest possible gray market or misrepresented inventory. Prior complaints about carrier locks/non-original packaging remain relevant.
Fulfillment and return policies.
Score: 70/100
Fulfillment and return policies.
"Amazonās A-Z Guarantee adds a safety net, but pattern of returns disputes (seller denies receipt/claims damage) still present risk so buyer vigilance is needed."
Reason: Amazon itself fulfills the order and offers robust return/refund protections; buyer must act promptly if issues arise.
No external scam/counterfeit reports or manipulation complaints.
Score: 30/100
No external scam/counterfeit reports or manipulation complaints.
"Reports are recent, persistent, and come from highly credible complaint aggregators."
Reason: There are multiple public, well-documented accusations of return scams, misrepresentation, and product tampering/counterfeit risk from this seller.
Your Next Steps
-
1
If purchasing, use a credit card for strongest chargeback protection.
-
2
Carefully inspect the item on receipt. Do not discard packaging.
-
3
Test all advertised features. Check if device is truly new/unlocked and matches US specs.
-
4
If issues arise, initiate Amazonās A-Z Guarantee claim promptly (within Amazonās 30-day window).
-
5
Read recent verified purchase reviews for similar products from this seller.
Evidence & Citations
-
YY Wireless Trustpilot Reviews
Multiple allegations of misrepresented products and poor service.
-
BBB Complaints: Bayshine Trading Inc
Pattern of locked phones being sold as unlocked and denied refunds.
-
Amazon Seller Profile ā YY Wireless
Shows recent high ratings and high sales volume, but does not address off-Amazon conduct.
šµš» Keep investigating
Vet TikTok, eBay, Amazon, or Facebook Marketplace storefronts.
Detect dropshipped quality-switch scams on TikTok ShopSome shops advertise brand-name goods but ship random factory surplus once they capture payment. ScamAI looks at fulfill...
Read playbook ā Expose fake brand storefronts on TikTok ShopFake shops borrow official brand names, then redirect to off-platform checkout links. ScamAI inspects registration docs,...
Read playbook ā