Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

The eBay seller TovaTreasuresNFinds appears to be a well-established, legitimate vendor with a solid reputation over years of trading. Their listing for the "Out Of This World Putty Blind Bag Alien Spaceship Toy Slime Goo UFO New" is described as new, with over 2,500 units sold. The seller’s feedback score is consistently 99.8% positive, and there are no credible reports of scam, fake reviews, or counterfeit products tied to their account. Price is close to, or a little above, large discount stores like Five Below. The only notable caution is a 'no returns' policy on this specific listing. Overall, TovaTreasuresNFinds shows strong commercial integrity and buyer security, with no red-flag behavior or scam allegations. 🛡️

Confidence Score

94%

Risk Insights

🏅

Longstanding, High-Volume eBay Seller

Over 10,000 items sold, including 2,500+ for this product

Feedback: ~99.8% positive across many years

No major scam or complaint records found

🛡️

Legitimate, Verified Product Source

Product also sold at large retailers like Five Below (≤$5)

No documented counterfeit issues or obvious product risks

⚠️

'No Returns' Policy Caveat

This listing does not accept general returns

eBay Money Back Guarantee still applies to 'not as described' claims

Contradictory Signals

While the lack of general returns is less ideal, it is mitigated by eBay's Money Back Guarantee and the seller’s otherwise strong track record.

Signal A: Seller’s profile, history, and external checks indicate legitimacy and positive reputation.

Signal B: Listing has a 'no returns' policy, which is less buyer-friendly than the marketplace norm.

Category Scores

Identity 93/100

Reputation 95/100

Technical 85/100

Content 92/100

Legal 97/100

Business Validity 95/100

Red Flags & Warnings

This listing is set as 'no returns,' meaning buyer-initiated returns are not explicitly allowed except for items not as described.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity verifiable and matches listing

Score: 98/100

Passed

"Single consistent eBay identity observed with an established transaction history."

Reason: Seller username, store name, and linked profile are consistent across product and store pages.

Seller reputation (feedback, history, external complaints)

Score: 96/100

Passed

"Score slightly discounted due to minor (sub-1%) negative buyer feedback, typical for this volume."

Reason: Extensive positive ratings and no mainstream complaints or scam reports exist, as shown in third-party reputation checks.

Product authenticity and consistency

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Comparable retail prices and product photos. Bulk and close substitutes are common at legitimate sellers."

Reason: Product is a generic putty toy sold at discount stores. No fake versions or major quality complaints found.

Fulfillment and order pattern integrity

Score: 93/100

Passed

"Sold quantity and repeat product lines signal stable fulfillment. No non-delivery pattern."

Reason: eBay’s systems handle payment, shipping, and buyer protection. Prompt shipping (average 1–2 days) and thousands sold.

Review authenticity and manipulation checks

Score: 86/100

Passed

"Volume of high reviews is normal for long-term eBay businesses; eBay auto-cleans fake reviews per 2024 update."

Reason: Reddit and Fakespot minor skepticism was found, but no study, no complaints, and seller passes eBay’s strict fake review filters.

Return policy transparency and consumer rights

Score: 75/100

Passed

"No evidence of systematic denial of legitimate returns, but policy is less generous than some sellers."

Reason: While this listing is 'no returns,' eBay’s Money Back Guarantee protects buyers for not-as-described claims.

Your Next Steps

1

Purchase via eBay’s official checkout to retain Money Back Guarantee protection.
2

If authenticity or item description is a concern, use eBay’s buyer–seller message function to request more photos or details.
3

Avoid direct off-platform communication or payment, as with all online marketplaces.
4

If you receive an item not as described or fake, document immediately with photos and open an eBay dispute promptly.

Evidence & Citations

Perplexity External Market and Reputation Check – TovaTreasuresNFinds (eBay)
Combined forum, review, and marketplace search yielded no scam complaints or authenticity warnings. Feedback metrics and product scope validated.
eBay Seller & Product Listing Metadata
Seller reputation, transactional security, and product details confirmed using eBay’s listing and seller profile data.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →