Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

This eBay listing features a 2 oz .999 Silver Round designed after the 1878 Morgan dollar, offered by Belleair Coins Gold & Diamonds. The seller, 'belleaircoins', has a well-established eBay presence, operating a physical store in Largo, Florida since 1972. Their store offers over 2,100 items, mostly coins, bullion, and collectible currency, with a 100% feedback score and a strong reputation both locally and online. Over 51,000 units of this specific listing have been sold—a sign of high transaction volume and marketplace trust. No credible evidence points to fake reviews or the sale of counterfeit products. The primary risk is with premium pricing: this item is listed at $135, while reputable bullion dealers like APMEX and Golden State Mint offer similar 2 oz Morgan-style rounds for about $72–$153, depending on the current silver price and order volume—putting this eBay listing in the higher end of that range. The return policy (14 days, seller pays return shipping) and accepted payment methods (PayPal, Venmo, credit cards) provide standard buyer protection. If you're seeking authenticity, reliable fulfillment, and a safe transaction, this listing meets expectations. Just compare silver prices and premiums before purchasing. 🛡️

Confidence Score

94%

Risk Insights

🏅

Trusted Seller—High Volume

Over 51,000 units sold, 2,100+ listings, long-term eBay history

Physical storefront operating since 1972

Positive public and buyer reputation

💲

Market Premium: Compare Prices

Listed price ($135) higher than APMEX's low end but within range for legitimate 2 oz rounds

Premium could reflect retail setting or brand premium

🛡️

eBay Buyer Protections

14-day returns, multiple payment options, seller pays for return shipping

Standard eBay channels for communication and dispute resolution

Contradictory Signals

The seller commands higher prices, but there is no sign of counterfeiting or deceptive practices—just marketplace premium. This is common on retail or collectible-focused platforms.

Signal A: Seller has an extensive, proven transaction record and strong local presence.

Signal B: Listing price is not the lowest versus bullion dealers.

Category Scores

Identity 95/100

Reputation 93/100

Technical 92/100

Content 90/100

Legal 95/100

Business Validity 95/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Item price is above the absolute lowest price available from major online silver dealers for similar 2 oz rounds, which may deter bargain shoppers.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller is a verified, long-term business with established reputation.

Score: 95/100

Passed

"A+ feedback, high sales, and in-person track record increase trust."

Reason: Belleair Coins Gold & Diamonds has operated since 1972, runs a brick-and-mortar location, and maintains an active, high-volume presence on eBay.

No evidence of fake reviews or counterfeit products.

Score: 92/100

Passed

"Third-party scams have been reported with eBay generally, but not this seller."

Reason: Neither web search nor user forums report fake reviews or counterfeit allegations for this seller or specific listing.

Listing content is consistent, professional, and matches seller inventory.

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Many similar items sold; images and details match other legitimate listings."

Reason: Listing images, descriptions, and metadata are consistent with the seller's broader inventory and professional standards.

Fulfills eBay's buyer protection practices (returns, payments, communication).

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Provides standard protections for buyers."

Reason: Return policy (14 days, seller pays shipping), broad payment methods, and communication options align with eBay's safety standards.

Commercial price and value integrity vs. market.

Score: 73/100

Passed

"Not suspicious; just a higher premium compared to bulk or direct sources."

Reason: The price ($135) fits within the retail range from mainstream dealers, though it is not the lowest available. Market conditions can affect premiums.

No sign of manipulated sales patterns or fake demand.

Score: 94/100

Passed

"Over 51,000 units sold supports authentic demand."

Reason: Sales history is substantial and steady; no unnatural spikes or feedback anomalies.

Your Next Steps

1

Review the seller's detailed feedback and recent transactions for added peace of mind.
2

Compare live silver prices and the premium over spot (major dealers like APMEX or Golden State Mint) before purchase.
3

If in doubt about authenticity, request additional documentation or verification from the seller.
4

Keep records of your transaction and communicate via eBay's official messaging tools.

Evidence & Citations

Belleair Coins Gold & Diamonds - Official Storefront
Shows seller's full listing inventory, branding, and online presence.
Independent search: No fake reviews or counterfeit product evidence
Belleair Coins is a real business with long physical presence. No scam discussions referenced for its eBay activity.
APMEX product page: 2 oz Morgan Design Silver Round
For benchmarking price and bullion specifics from a top-rated online seller.
Golden State Mint: 2 oz Morgan Silver Round
Another benchmark source for current silver round pricing.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →