Recommendation

Caution

Overall Summary

Suspicious

Why we think so

This eBay listing offers a 10-piece set of Desert Ironwood bookmatched burl knife scales from seller "salma30" for $160 USD with free shipping. The seller reports a feedback score of 100 and has sold 72 units of this listing, yet does not accept returns. There's no public evidence of scam complaints, counterfeit accusations, or review manipulation linked to this seller. A price check shows $160 is in line with one other specialist shop, while larger wood retailers and Etsy sellers list similar products at a wide range of prices. 📦 The seller is location-verified in Tucson, Arizona, and accepts major payment methods like PayPal, credit cards, and Google Pay. Because there is limited public background and the seller profile page displays as very sparse or empty, if you're interested, review the seller's feedback page for more direct buyer experiences before purchase.

Confidence Score

63%

Risk Insights

🟢

No major scam reports found

Seller has no public scam complaints.

Product details and price appear in line with specialty suppliers.

🟡

Sparse seller profile and buyer protection limits

eBay profile is mostly empty despite 72 recorded sales.

Strict no-returns policy raises buyer risk.

Contradictory Signals

The mismatch between sales volume and online reputation detail could reflect a privacy-focused or very small-scale seller, but it also makes vetting more difficult.

Signal A: Seller shows 72 items sold and a 100 feedback score, which suggests history.

Signal B: Seller store/profile is mostly empty and lacks visible detailed review history.

Category Scores

Identity 55/100

Reputation 60/100

Technical 80/100

Content 65/100

Legal 80/100

Business Validity 60/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Sparse or empty eBay seller profile—not typical for someone with multiple sales and high feedback.
Strict no-returns policy removes a major buyer protection avenue.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller History & Identity Consistency

Score: 55/100

Failed

"This can occur for newer or low-volume sellers but is unusual for someone with 72 sales. It makes full trust harder to establish."

Reason: The eBay seller profile is mostly empty—lacking detailed reputation data and inventory that are usually present for established sellers.

Review & Buyer Feedback Verification

Score: 55/100

Failed

"Important buyer feedback is referenced but not available for direct review from outside the eBay system."

Reason: Direct reviews or ratings for this seller and product are not visible from evidence, preventing third-party validation.

Product and Price Consistency

Score: 75/100

Passed

"No evidence of pricing substantially below market rates, which is typical of questionable or scam listings."

Reason: Price and description are consistent with at least one specialist site, suggesting competitive, market-aligned pricing.

Fulfillment, Payment, and Returns Policy

Score: 60/100

Failed

"While payment options and free shipping are strong, the lack of returns puts all risk on the buyer."

Reason: Strict no-returns policy weakens consumer protection and could deter buyers concerned about product accuracy or quality.

Counterfeit, Scam, or Manipulation Signals

Score: 80/100

Passed

"No credible complaints or negative press attach to seller "salma30" for this item or other listings."

Reason: No counterfeit or scam allegations surface in external sources and the product details are plausible.

Business Validity & Transparency

Score: 60/100

Failed

"A fuller business profile provides greater trust. This account appears individually operated and not a business."

Reason: Lack of a complete store profile and verified business details introduces some transparency risk.

Your Next Steps

1

Check the seller's feedback in detail to assess recent buyer satisfaction.
2

Before purchasing, contact the seller with any product-specific questions to gauge responsiveness.
3

Pay with a protected method (PayPal, credit card) for buyer security.
4

Request additional photos or proof of inventory if you need further assurance.
5

Consider the strict return policy and ensure you are comfortable with this risk.

Evidence & Citations

eBay item listing for DESERT IRONWOOD BOOKMATCH BURL PAIR H F 10 PZAS 5.2X1.7X3/8 LOT BM#9
Details the item description, sales history (72 sold), seller feedback, no-returns policy, and payment information.
Perplexity search: Counterfeits, scam reports, and price comparison for Desert Ironwood listing
No external scam or counterfeit reports found; price is comparable to a reputable bench seller.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...

Read playbook →

Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver

Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...

Read playbook →