Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

This eBay listing offered a brand new, sealed 1993 Sony CD of Jamiroquai's "Emergency On Planet Earth" for £3, sold by user robmcq_16 from Altrincham, UK, with no returns accepted. The seller displays a high feedback score (99.5%) and has a record of over 560 units sold for this item, yet the listing is now marked as sold out. There are no third-party reports linking this seller to scams, counterfeit activity, or manipulated feedback. The price is notably lower than collector expectations for authentic, sealed 1993 editions but is not out of range for standard retail reissues. No significant red flags are present, though the lack of a returns policy means buyers must rely on eBay's Money Back Guarantee for problems. Always review photos and request detail about provenance when buying vintage sealed media.🛡️

Confidence Score

90%

Risk Insights

🛒

High Feedback, Strong Track Record

99.5% positive feedback

560+ units sold of this item

No scam or counterfeit complaints found

📦

No Returns Accepted

No discretionary returns allowed by seller

eBay Money Back Guarantee still applies

💷

Price Consistent with Market Norms

£3 sale price falls within retail reissue band

Notably less than rare sealed 1993 collector's copies

Contradictory Signals

The lack of a return policy is typically a yellow flag, but the volume and feedback signal a low likelihood of problems for this specific transaction.

Signal A: High-volume sales with excellent feedback indicate trustworthiness.

Signal B: Seller offers no returns, which sometimes correlates with increased risk.

Category Scores

Identity 92/100

Reputation 90/100

Technical 85/100

Content 88/100

Legal 90/100

Business Validity 91/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Seller accepts no returns, limiting recourse if issues arise outside official eBay processes.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller Reputation: Feedback and Sales History

Score: 95/100

Passed

"A long positive transaction history on a specific product strongly suggests authentic commercial operation."

Reason: The seller has a near-perfect feedback score (99.5%) and has sold over 560 units of this item, indicating trust from many buyers.

Product Authenticity: Risk of Counterfeits

Score: 85/100

Passed

"Collectors should still review shrinkwrap, matrix/runout codes, and label details for full verification."

Reason: There's no direct evidence this specific CD/CD edition is commonly counterfeited, nor are there active complaints about this seller relating to fakes.

Listing and Photo Consistency

Score: 87/100

Passed

"No evidence of obvious stock image misuse or image inconsistency."

Reason: Photos appear typical for a new/sealed CD; seller's record of high-volume sales adds credibility.

Fulfillment and Payment Protection

Score: 90/100

Passed

"As long as transactions remain on-platform, buyers enjoy eBay protection for non-delivery or misrepresented items."

Reason: eBay's Money Back Guarantee applies and standard payment options (PayPal, cards, bank) are accepted.

Return Policy & Buyer Recourse

Score: 65/100

Failed

"eBay's guarantee mitigates risk for items 'not as described,' but discretionary returns for fit/condition are not supported."

Reason: The seller's 'No returns accepted' stance reduces convenience and may concern collectors or resellers.

External Reputation & Complaints

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Cautious buyers should still periodically check for new reviews or complaint patterns."

Reason: No legitimate public forum or news results identify robmcq_16 as a scammer or source of problems.

Your Next Steps

1

If you buy rare media, ask the seller for close-up photos of discs, shrinkwrap, barcodes, and any matrix codes to confirm authenticity.
2

Pay through eBay's managed payment system or PayPal to retain buyer protections.
3

If the item does not arrive or matches the listing poorly, file a dispute within eBay’s protection window.
4

For high-value collector items, consider comparing sold prices and item details with verified sources (e.g., Discogs, Popsike) to check for typical counterfeit signals.

Evidence & Citations

eBay Product Listing for robmcq_16
Source of seller score, listing data, and transaction quantity.
Independent scam/complaint search results
No public evidence found of scam activity or counterfeit complaints for this user.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →