Recommendation

Caution

Overall Summary

Suspicious

Why we think so

The eBay seller 'winchester-79' listed a new, sealed WD_BLACK 2TB SN850X NVMe Gaming SSD for $112.50, shipping from Roy, Utah. This seller has a perfect feedback score (100) and has sold 172 units of this item, but currently has none available. Their eBay profile lacks a store banner or details, but basic seller info is visible. Price appears lower than most mainstream retailers, where this SSD usually sells for around $140–$160. There’s no public evidence linking this seller to fake reviews or counterfeit goods. The listing offers buyer protections like PayPal, but the seller does not accept returns, which is unusual for electronics. 🛡️ Proceed with some caution: confirm product authenticity upon receipt and consider the no-returns policy before purchasing.

Confidence Score

68%

Risk Insights

🟢

No Counterfeit Reports Found

Winchester-79 not cited in scam or fake review forums.

No direct complaints on eBay or collector sites.

🟡

Below-Market Price on New SSD

Listed SSD is $30–50 below typical US retail for this model.

Such pricing is attractive but not highly abnormal for high-volume sellers.

⚠️

No Returns May Limit Buyer Protection

The seller does not accept returns even on new items.

This policy is rare for electronics and increases buyer risk.

🛒

Solid Seller Feedback and Sales Record

100 feedback score, over 170 units sold of this item.

No visible surge in negative ratings.

Contradictory Signals

While feedback and sales are excellent, these restrictive terms and low pricing are not typical of mainstream US retail for electronics. Risk is moderate, not negligible.

Signal A: Perfect seller feedback, high volume sold, no complaints noted.

Signal B: Seller restricts returns on pricey new electronics, and price is unusually low.

Category Scores

Identity 65/100

Reputation 75/100

Technical 65/100

Content 70/100

Legal 60/100

Business Validity 70/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Seller does not accept returns on new, sealed electronics.
Sale price is well below market average. This can, though not always, indicate risk of gray market or questionable goods.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Verified Seller Identity

Score: 65/100

Passed

"The eBay ID 'winchester-79' has public sales and feedback, but their profile lacks a store banner or further company info."

Reason: Seller has a consistent track record on eBay. Basic profile and feedback visible, but store lacks detailed branding.

Reputation & Reviews

Score: 75/100

Passed

"Critically, there is no pattern of complaints about this seller, and collector forums do not list them among known counterfeiters."

Reason: No scam warnings or negative feedback about authenticity found. Seller has 100 feedback, all positive.

Listing Content Accuracy

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Product specs (model, capacity, compatibility) in the listing match official Western Digital details."

Reason: Listing details and photos match the actual WD_BLACK SSD and align with manufacturer specs.

Product/Stock Consistency

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Images and specifications have stayed static throughout multiple sales."

Reason: Sold over 170 units with consistent product images. No abrupt changes or mismatches in descriptions.

Fulfillment & Returns

Score: 45/100

Failed

"Most reputable eBay electronics sellers accept returns within 30 days, especially for new items."

Reason: The seller does not accept returns on expensive electronics—a significant drawback for buyers.

Market Pricing and Supply Legitimacy

Score: 60/100

Failed

"The eBay price is ~$30–50 below most mainstream prices, which is unusual for new stock direct from US sellers."

Reason: Price is notably low compared to large retailers, which could indicate gray market goods, though not definitively counterfeit.

Your Next Steps

1

Check seller's full feedback history for any recent complaints about non-delivery or authenticity.
2

If you buy, verify the product’s serial number and factory markings immediately on arrival.
3

Use a protected payment method (e.g., PayPal) for extra recourse in case of issues.
4

Be cautious about the no-return policy, especially with lower-than-market price electronics.

Evidence & Citations

eBay Listing and Seller Info (winchester-79)
Pricing, stock, and seller feedback pulled directly from listing.
Price Comparisons – WD_BLACK 2TB SN850X
Marketplace pricing and legitimacy benchmarks cross-referenced.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...

Read playbook →

Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver

Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...

Read playbook →