WebVetted Beta
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
Why we think so

The eBay listing from user tedbodega offers a pair of Maison Margiela x Gentle Monster MM117 C1 sunglasses, described as 100% original and new with tags, at a price point that appears consistent with global retail pricing for this luxury item. Despite selling nearly 200 units and offering standard payment and return options, key signals are missing: there are no visible seller feedback, no reputation history, and no buyer reviews for this seller, which is unusual on eBay for a seller with a high sale count. The listing provides clear product images and a regular location (New York, US), but the lack of reputation data and feedback transparency make the purchase riskier compared to established/Top Rated eBay sellers or direct authorized boutiques. Proceed with caution, especially for high-value designer goods. 🕵️‍♂️

Confidence Score
48%

Risk Insights

⚠️

Missing Seller Reputation

No visible feedback or reviews for a seller with 199 sales.
Typical for scam or new accounts; reduces buyer protection.
Verify directly or use secured payment/returns.
💸

Price in Line with Official Retail

Listed price closely matches brand’s MSRP.
Price not suspiciously low, lowering counterfeit risk.

Contradictory Signals

While pricing and product alignment suggest a legitimate item, the absence of seller history is a significant unresolved risk.

Signal A: Price matches legitimate MM117 C1 retail.

Signal B: Seller has zero visible feedback or reviews.

Category Scores

Identity 25/100
Reputation 10/100
Technical 60/100
Content 75/100
Legal 60/100
Business Validity 35/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Seller's feedback score and buyer review history both missing despite high sales volume—unusual for eBay and reduces buyer confidence.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity verifiable

Score: 20/100
Failed

"For nearly 200 sales, some positive/negative buyer feedback should be present; its absence is an anomaly."

Reason: No public seller feedback, reputation, or verifiable business identity for 'tedbodega'.

Reputation and history

Score: 10/100
Failed

"Legitimate high-volume eBay sellers typically display feedback history, especially when selling designer goods."

Reason: No accessible track record or reviews as seller, which blocks trust building.

Product authenticity signals

Score: 60/100
Passed

"No immediate signs of counterfeit product or unusually low price, but image reuse and branding consistency require manual checking."

Reason: Listing price and images match the authentic product’s market value and appearance.

Commercial integrity (returns, payment, shipping)

Score: 70/100
Passed

"eBay’s Money Back Guarantee helps reduce buyer risk, but check detailed seller policy for hidden restrictions."

Reason: Standard payment methods (PayPal, credit cards) and a 30-day return policy offered.

Listing content consistency and transparency

Score: 75/100
Passed

"Absence of reviews is still a drawback, but the item description, pricing, and condition are transparently communicated."

Reason: Content is complete, descriptive, with multiple photos and clear product attributes.

No major legal or policy red flags

Score: 60/100
Passed

"Legal risk mostly centers on authenticity and lack of seller reputation, not direct policy violations."

Reason: Listing does not breach eBay listing rules; offers returns, clear payment, and shipping terms.

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    If you are considering buying, request detailed proof of authenticity (original receipt, serial number, packaging photos) from the seller.
  • 2
    Check the seller feedback profile directly for any recent neutral/negative reviews (may require being logged in on eBay).
  • 3
    Prefer buying luxury-branded goods from Top Rated Sellers or platforms with robust authentication for high-value items.
  • 4
    If you proceed, use eBay's Money Back Guarantee and pay only with protected methods (PayPal, credit card).
  • 5
    Report suspicious sellers to eBay if you spot evidence of counterfeits or rule-breaking behavior.

Evidence & Citations