Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

This eBay listing offers a pre-owned Alfred Angelo ivory and red satin wedding dress, sold by the user "ccharleson." The listing displays numerous actual photos, is marked as "Good" condition, and supports payments via eBay’s standard secure options like PayPal and Visa. Over 900 units of this dress (or similar listings) have sold. The seller "ccharleson" has a feedback score of 100, but the overall seller profile lacks further visible history, such as detailed store branding or a rich feedback breakdown. No reports of scams, counterfeit, or fake reviews tied to "ccharleson" appear in external web searches or eBay community forums. Pricing is within the lower range compared with other pre-owned Alfred Angelo dresses found on third-party sites, which aligns with expectations since Alfred Angelo went out of business in 2017 and most current stock is pre-owned. Still, as with any high-volume seller of discontinued brand names, buyers should read the listing carefully and use eBay’s buyer protections.🛡️

Confidence Score

83%

Risk Insights

✅

High sales volume, positive score

903 sold listings with a perfect feedback score (100)

Strong indication of an active and reliable seller

💲

Price in normal resale range

Listing price is consistent with other pre-owned Alfred Angelo dresses

Not unusually low (no clear sign of fraud or counterfeit intent)

🛡️

No confirmed scam complaints

No scam reports or complaints found for this seller on eBay or third-party forums

⚠️

Returns not accepted

No returns for this listing (common for used wedding dresses)

Reduces flexibility if you change your mind

Contradictory Signals

For some buyers, the lack of granular seller history and strict return policy could be a concern despite a strong overall sales record.

Signal A: The seller has a high sales record and perfect feedback.

Signal B: The seller does not provide detailed category or recent feedback information, and the return policy is restrictive.

Category Scores

Identity 90/100

Reputation 85/100

Technical 80/100

Content 80/100

Legal 85/100

Business Validity 80/100

Red Flags & Warnings

No detailed seller storefront, sales history, or granular recent feedback is visible in the seller’s eBay profile.
Returns are not accepted, which is common for some used wedding dresses, but reduces buyer flexibility.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller profile legitimacy

Score: 90/100

Passed

"A detailed storefront or breakdown of feedback by category is not available, but that is common for individual or occasional sellers."

Reason: The seller's eBay profile (ccharleson) is public, shows high-volume sales (903 items listed as sold), and holds a perfect feedback score. No scam reports surfaced in independent searches.

Listing content and photo authenticity

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Lack of detailed description text may limit some buyers, but images are strong."

Reason: Numerous original photos are included in the listing, showing real product characteristics that match the description (used, ivory & red, Alfred Angelo). No suspicious signs of image theft or stock photo use are present.

Price consistency and product type

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Alfred Angelo ceased production in 2017, so current market is exclusively pre-owned."

Reason: The price of £156.70 is in line with verified resale prices for similar Alfred Angelo dresses—not so low that it hints at counterfeiting or fraud.

External scam/counterfeit review signals

Score: 85/100

Passed

"General concern about eBay seller reviews does not impact this particular listing."

Reason: No external sources or eBay community posts complain about scams, counterfeit, or fake reviews specific to this seller.

Return and buyer protection policy

Score: 30/100

Failed

"eBay's 'item not as described' policy still applies if a major issue arises."

Reason: No returns accepted, standard for some used wedding attire but does reduce buyer recourse for sizing or undisclosed flaws.

Your Next Steps

1

Double-check the listing’s photos and written condition details before purchase.
2

Use PayPal, credit card, or another protected payment method.
3

Review the seller’s feedback (especially for recent negative or neutral reviews) before committing.
4

If in doubt about authenticity upon receipt, contact eBay support immediately using their 'item not as described' guarantee.

Evidence & Citations

eBay listing: Alfred Angelo Ivory & Red Satin Wedding Dress by ccharleson
Primary source of product and seller information, with feedback, photos, quantity sold, and full transaction details.
eBay community and third-party web forum results for 'ccharleson' scams/fakes
No specific scam or counterfeit complaints found for seller "ccharleson".
Resale market prices for Alfred Angelo wedding dresses
Supports normal price range for pre-owned Alfred Angelo dresses on legitimate sites.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver

Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...

Read playbook →

Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...

Read playbook →