WebVetted Beta
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
Why we think so

This eBay listing features a 30-pound bag of Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach Adult Dog Food (Salmon & Rice) for $54.99, sold by the user 'kacrom-7.' The listing claims the product is brand new and recently sold 4 units in 24 hours, with a total of 339 units sold. There are no public reviews or ratings on the seller's profile, and the seller does not appear in external scam or counterfeit complaints. However, the price is significantly lower than leading legitimate sellers (e.g., Amazon lists this bag for about $89), which may signal potential risk. The seller does not offer returns and provides limited business identity. There is no direct evidence of counterfeit or scam behavior, but the lack of seller feedback and unusually low price warrant caution. ✅ The product details, images, and accepted payment methods appear typical for eBay listings, but the price/value gap is a concern.

Confidence Score
28%

Risk Insights

⚠️

Low Seller Visibility

No ratings, reviews, or store information for 'kacrom-7'.
Hard to verify trustworthiness.
💲

Suspiciously Low Price

Listed at $54.99; Amazon's lowest is $89 for the same product.
Steep discounts frequently signal risk of gray market or counterfeit goods.

Product Presentation Matches Official Listings

All ingredient and packaging photos match Purina's typical branding.
Item located in the US, accepts standard eBay payments.

Contradictory Signals

High sales volume should generate at least minimal feedback or reviews; this mismatch raises concerns about manipulated sales data, new/recycled accounts, or private feedback.

Signal A: Listing claims 339 units sold (suggests real activity).

Signal B: Seller profile shows zero feedback and no visible reputation (suggests inexperience or low trust).

Even with authentic-seeming presentation, price and policy signals warrant careful verification.

Signal A: Product images and details match authentic Purina specifications.

Signal B: Price well below market and no returns accepted (counterfeit risk).

Category Scores

Identity 15/100
Reputation 10/100
Technical 65/100
Content 75/100
Legal 35/100
Business Validity 20/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Zero seller feedback or public reputation history makes it hard to verify legitimacy.
  • Listing price is much lower than market rate for identical products, which is a common sign of counterfeiting, diversion or gray market sourcing.
  • No returns accepted, which removes a key buyer protection feature.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity and business profile

Score: 10/100
Failed

"A reputable eBay seller should have visible feedback history, business address, and store details."

Reason: No seller ratings or business details are available for 'kacrom-7'. Buyers cannot assess their track record or legitimacy.

Seller reputation and review authenticity

Score: 10/100
Failed

"The absence of both positive and negative feedback is rare for a seller with hundreds of product sales."

Reason: There is no feedback, ratings, or reviews for the seller, and no evidence of fake or manipulated reviews, making reputation impossible to evaluate.

Consistent, credible product details

Score: 80/100
Passed

"Clear product specs, name, main ingredient, model, and features match official offerings."

Reason: Product attributes, images, and branding are consistent with legitimate Purina listings.

Pricing and value alignment with market

Score: 10/100
Failed

"Amazon and other sources confirm the typical new price for this bag is $80–$90."

Reason: Price is $54.99, well below typical $89 retail price for this product. Such underpricing is often associated with risk of counterfeit or diverted goods.

Order fulfillment and inventory transparency

Score: 70/100
Passed

"Still, sales numbers can sometimes be manipulated and should not be trusted as the sole measure of reliability."

Reason: Listing claims 339 sold with recent purchase activity and displays available quantity. This is typical for an active eBay seller.

Consumer protections (returns, disputes)

Score: 20/100
Failed

"Normal eBay protection applies, but refunding without a return option may be tougher."

Reason: Seller does not accept returns. Lack of return policy places more risk on the buyer if goods are not as described.

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    Only consider purchasing if you are comfortable with the risk of no returns and possible counterfeit goods.
  • 2
    Carefully inspect the product upon delivery; compare packaging, labeling, and product details to official Purina products.
  • 3
    Consider reaching out to the seller directly for additional details or proof of authenticity.
  • 4
    Consider safer alternatives from eBay sellers with established positive feedback or from major retailers with reliable return policies.
  • 5
    If you proceed, use payment methods that provide purchase protection (e.g., PayPal, major credit card).

Evidence & Citations