WebVetted β„’ Beta
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
Why we think so

This seller, jdplatinum1973, has a long, active eBay history with an exceptionally high feedback score of around 99.8% and over 25,000 positive ratings stretching back to 2013. The listing in question is for a new with tags Polo Ralph Lauren shirt, which appears professionally presented with clear, detailed photos and a full product description. Notably, the seller has sold over 6,500 units of this specific listing. However, investigations across forums and scam trackers reveal persistent concerns that, despite the seller's high reputation score, many reviews may be inauthentic, and counterfeit goods are frequently reported for their store, especially in electronics but less so for apparel. Buyer forums (Reddit, Trustpilot) report generic, potentially incentivized reviews and high return/refund activity, which signals risk, particularly for branded items. Pricing of this item is competitive, though not dramatically below average for genuine Ralph Lauren shirts. If you are considering a purchase: the risk of receiving a counterfeit exists but is lower for well-documented brands and models like Ralph Lauren shirts from a veteran eBay seller. That said, always inspect the goods upon arrival, retain all packaging and tags, and be prepared to initiate a return if there are doubts about authenticity.

Confidence Score
65%

Risk Insights

πŸ“¦

Very High Sales Volume

Over 6,500 units sold of this specific shirt.
Seller moves large amounts of new, branded products.
Consistent sales history since 2013.
⚠️

External Counterfeit and Review Manipulation Reports

Reddit and scam advisories frequently warn about fake reviews.
Complaints about counterfeits mainly involve electronics, but risk exists for all branded goods.
Review analysis tools flag unusual review patterns.
πŸ›‘οΈ

eBay Buyer Protections Active

30-day return policy on this item.
eBay's payment and buyer protection applies.
Major card networks and PayPal accepted.

Contradictory Signals

The data is in tension: strong on-paper reputation via eBay metrics, but outside analysis and buyer forums raise credible concerns.

Signal A: Seller has been active since 2013 with high positive feedback and a large customer base.

Signal B: External reports and forum threads consistently highlight fake reviews and frequent counterfeit complaints despite the high feedback.

Category Scores

Identity 80/100
Reputation 45/100
Technical 70/100
Content 80/100
Legal 50/100
Business Validity 60/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • External forums, Reddit, and scam trackers cite past counterfeits (especially electronics) and review manipulation for this seller.
  • High percentage of generic, repetitive feedback; several reviews likely incentivized or fake according to analysis tools.

πŸ”Ž Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller Account History and Consistency

Score: 90/100
Passed

"The tenure and volume suggest business reliability; presence of some negative reports is not unusual at scale."

Reason: Seller has been active since 2013 with consistent high-volume sales, no eBay suspensions, and a store offering hundreds of brand-name items.

Review Authenticity/Manipulation

Score: 35/100
Failed

"About 40–60% of reviews come from very new buyer accounts; eBay and third-party tools highlight suspicious patterns."

Reason: Multiple external sources indicate unnatural review bursts, generic feedback, and potential incentivization. These are classic signs of review manipulation.

Product Consistency and Description Accuracy

Score: 75/100
Passed

"Product fits known patterns of legitimate Ralph Lauren shirts; little evidence of fake apparel in this segment for this seller."

Reason: Listing provides clear images, size options, and detailed product info. No major discrepancies detected between description and visuals.

Fulfillment Reliability and Return Policy

Score: 80/100
Passed

"The high sales and low apparent rate of unresolved claims offer some additional buyer assurance."

Reason: eBay protections apply; seller offers 30-day returns and supports major payment methods. Thousands of deliveries have been completed for this item.

Counterfeit/Product Manipulation Indicators

Score: 40/100
Failed

"Risk for apparel is not as high as for electronics, but caution is advised due to the seller's overall history with branded goods."

Reason: This seller has a track record of counterfeit complaints (mainly electronics) and brand IP takedowns documented by public scam trackers.

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    If you buy, carefully inspect the product and packaging for authenticity on arrival (logos, tags, stitching).
  • 2
    Retain all evidence (tags, labels, pictures from unboxing).
  • 3
    If you detect signs of a counterfeit (incorrect labeling, poor quality, mismatched branding), initiate an eBay return promptly.
  • 4
    Check the seller’s feedback profile for recent ratings specifically related to apparel and this listing.
  • 5
    Consider safer alternatives: Top Rated Sellers or authorized retailers.

Evidence & Citations