Ebay Due Diligence
Report for Tandteetreasures
Why we think so
This eBay listing is for a used Xbox 360 S White Special Edition Console, which comes with a controller, 10 games, and a 250GB hard drive. The seller, tandteetreasures, displays a feedback score of 100. Over 1,300 units have reportedly been sold through this page. The product ships from Staten Island, NY, for a $50 fee, and the seller does not accept returns. While the item’s images and product details seem thorough, there are serious questions about the seller’s broader reputation, with documented patterns of fake reviews and complaints of counterfeit or low-quality items on several aggregator sites and discussion forums. Third-party review analysis tools have flagged a high percentage of suspicious reviews connected to this seller, and some buyers have reported receiving products not as described. Overall, the listing's price and presentation appear typical for this console bundle, but buyer risk is elevated due to credibility and authenticity concerns. 🛑
Risk Insights
Seller Shows Signs of Fake Review Manipulation
Counterfeit Product Complaints Documented
Over 1,300 Recorded Sales on The Specific Listing
Contradictory Signals
While the visual and numerical transaction history looks legitimate, the overwhelmingly negative sentiment and confirmed fake review patterns in external analyses sharply reduce trust in authenticity.
Signal A: The listing includes many authentic-looking product images and a high volume of recorded sales.
Signal B: Third-party tools and forums consistently flag this seller for fake reviews and counterfeit item complaints.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
-
High proportion of potentially fake/suspicious reviews detected by automated tools.
-
Repeated buyer complaints about counterfeit goods and poor customer service.
-
No returns accepted, limiting recourse if you receive a misrepresented or faulty product.
🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis
Seller identity and contact legitimacy
Seller identity and contact legitimacy
"Visible branding (tandteetreasures) is consistent with the eBay account, but outside evidence claims possible misrepresentation about location or operations."
Reason: The seller's display name and profile match across the listing and seller pages, but external reports question the true business identity and shipment origins.
Historical reputation and customer feedback analysis
Historical reputation and customer feedback analysis
"Fakespot and ReviewMeta detect large volumes of potentially fake reviews; buyers highlight issues in Reddit threads."
Reason: Automated review analyzers and user forums cite patterns of fake feedback, suspicious review bursts, and complaints about low-quality or fake items.
Listing accuracy, product details, and visual presentation
Listing accuracy, product details, and visual presentation
"Clear images, detailed specs, and sold quantity visible. No immediate visual indicators of stock photo misuse for this specific product."
Reason: The product description, gallery, and pricing are consistent with Xbox 360 resale standards. Presentation is thorough and typical for eBay listings.
Counterfeit, misrepresentation, or manipulation risk
Counterfeit, misrepresentation, or manipulation risk
"Trustpilot, BBB, and eBay reviews, corroborated by aggregator sites, document recurring user allegations and negative experiences."
Reason: Repeat complaints on multiple third-party sources highlight counterfeit and quality issues, including items arriving not as described.
Fulfillment, shipping practices, and returns policy
Fulfillment, shipping practices, and returns policy
"High shipping fee ($50) and lack of returns are notable risks. Delayed or out-of-country fulfillment possible according to external feedback."
Reason: The listing ships from the US, but external reports describe some items shipping from China. No returns accepted, which is unfavorable for buyers.
Legal/regulatory and eBay policy compliance
Legal/regulatory and eBay policy compliance
"Repeated community and review site reports; no formal bans or suspensions as of the reporting date, but elevated user disputes."
Reason: No record of official eBay action, but the seller’s practices (alleged fake reviews, counterfeit) run counter to marketplace policies.
Your Next Steps
-
1If you decide to purchase, immediately photograph the unboxing and condition for documentation.
-
2Check received items for authenticity (compare against official product details, serials, and packaging).
-
3Document and report any discrepancies or counterfeit signs to eBay’s buyer protection, and request a refund if the item does not match the listing.
-
4Research alternative sellers with higher, verifiable reputations (10,000+ feedback, Top-Rated Seller status).
-
5Avoid purchasing if you prefer to eliminate risk: credible third parties and past buyers flag serious seller integrity issues.
Evidence & Citations
-
tandteetreasures eBay Product Listing
Listing shows used Xbox 360 bundle, detailed images, 1305 sold, US-based shipping, and no returns.
-
Seller Review and Counterfeit Product Analysis
Multiple forum threads and review aggregator analyses (e.g., Fakespot, ReviewMeta) flag this seller for review manipulation and counterfeit items.
🕵🏻 Keep investigating
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online
Read playbook →Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.
Read playbook →