WebVetted ™ Beta
+ New Report

Ebay Due Diligence
Report for House Of PenJones

Report Date December 28, 2025
Recommendation
Avoid
Overall Summary
Scam
Why we think so

This eBay listing for a Cartier Must de Cartier Black Calfskin Leather Card Holder at $110.19 is offered by House of PenJones, an established seller based in Oklahoma. At first glance, the seller presents as reputable and has completed at least 1,000 successful transactions on this item alone. The store displays high feedback ratings and offers a variety of luxury goods, mainly well-known designer accessories. However, multiple independent analyses flag House of PenJones as a frequent source of replica or counterfeit goods—particularly high-end pens and wallets that visually mimic originals. External reviews and forum discussions consistently point to patterns like clearly marked replica products, deceptive packaging, and feedback that appears manipulated. The price here is also far below verified retail or typical resale market values for genuine Cartier wallets, raising strong concerns about authenticity. Despite positive seller metrics within eBay’s ecosystem, a significant body of third-party evidence and consumer complaints warn buyers to avoid luxury-branded goods from this storefront to prevent receiving non-authentic merchandise. ⚠️

Confidence Score
20%

Risk Insights

⚠️

High risk of counterfeit goods

Seller listings are explicitly described as replicas or homages.
Third-party reviews confirm receipt of non-authentic goods.
Pricing is far below authentic Cartier market rates.
🚩

Fake review pattern

Fakespot/ReviewMeta grade reviews as unreliable.
Generic praise is repeated, negative feedback suppressed.
eBay already removed suspicious reviews from the account.
🛡️

Returns and eBay buyer protection present

eBay Buyer Protection can help if you file a dispute quickly.
Return window is 14 days, though buyer pays return shipping.

Contradictory Signals

eBay’s own scores reflect successful transaction completions, but do not guarantee product legitimacy; high volume and positive feedback can mask counterfeit activity with volume-based review manipulation.

Signal A: Seller has high feedback scores and transaction volume on eBay.

Signal B: External review and product authentication services give the seller failing grades and document consistent counterfeit sales.

Category Scores

Identity 40/100
Reputation 20/100
Technical 35/100
Content 20/100
Legal 10/100
Business Validity 15/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Numerous external reports verify that items described and sold by this seller are openly labeled as replicas, mirroring Cartier packaging and branding, which constitutes trademark infringement and clear counterfeiting.
  • Review patterns are unnatural: Fakespot and ReviewMeta flag ~85% suspicious reviews, generic praise is heavily repeated, and eBay itself has removed a large set of reviews for manipulation.
  • Product pricing is implausibly low compared to authentic Cartier offerings—a hallmark of counterfeit or replica sales, not discount retail.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity is consistent and verifiable

Score: 40/100
Failed

"Their high ratings stem largely from feedback linked to replica or non-genuine goods, not genuine authentication."

Reason: Seller account 'House of PenJones' is verified in eBay’s internal system, but reputation is widely questioned due to counterfeit activity.

Product authenticity and accuracy

Score: 10/100
Failed

"Listings themselves may state 'replica' or 'homage'—clearly defining non-authentic products, as with this Cartier wallet."

Reason: Strong third-party evidence and feedback confirm that this seller's listings regularly feature replica or counterfeit products.

Review authenticity and manipulation risk

Score: 20/100
Failed

"Patterns include generic repeated praise and deleted/filtered negative reviews."

Reason: Automated and external review analysis tools have consistently graded reviews as highly suspicious and likely manipulated.

Listing details match category and market

Score: 35/100
Failed

"This is a key risk factor for counterfeits, especially in the luxury accessories niche."

Reason: Product price is implausibly low for a genuine Cartier wallet and does not match legitimate market or brand channel offers.

Fulfillment, payment, and buyer protection provisions

Score: 70/100
Passed

"This offers a safety net for buyers who initiate a dispute soon after delivery."

Reason: The listing supports eBay’s full set of payment and remediation tools (PayPal, Venmo, cards, eBay returns).

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    Do NOT purchase this listing if you are seeking an authentic Cartier wallet.
  • 2
    Report the listing to eBay using the 'Report Item' tool for suspected counterfeiting and IP infringement.
  • 3
    If you have already bought the item, document all communications and packaging details, and open a case with eBay Buyer Protection immediately.
  • 4
    Consider only purchasing branded luxury goods from official boutiques or authorized resellers, where authenticity is contractually guaranteed.

Evidence & Citations

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →
🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →
Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →