Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

Purple Penelope—operating as the eBay store "gloriahallelujahllc"—offers a "Vintage A Choice of Gods Mix Lot of 7 Books Softcover by Clifford D. Simak" for $39.39, shipping from Grovetown, Georgia. The seller stands out as highly established, with over 1,400 sales for the specific listing and a 99.7% feedback score from a store holding over 1,600 items. The listing features clear, multiple photos and transparent condition notes ("Pre-Owned, Acceptable Condition"), plus a 30-day return policy with free seller-paid shipping, solidifying buyer protection. External checks find no public complaints or scam reports against 'Purple Penelope,' nor indications of fake reviews or counterfeit merchandise. Price comparison shows similar Simak books selling individually for $20–$50, making the 7-book set price reasonable—especially given the flexibility in vintage book valuations. No red flags emerge in seller conduct, listing details, or return/payment practices. Buyers benefit from eBay’s Money Back Guarantee and a professional seller history, making this listing broadly trustworthy for typical collectors or book enthusiasts. 🛡️

Confidence Score

95%

Risk Insights

🛡️

Established seller with high trust

99.7% positive feedback and 1,400+ sales for this item

Over 1,600 active listings in store

Consistent branding and location history

💵

Product matches market pricing

Single Simak books often $20–50; 7-book lot for $39.39 is within expected range

No 'too good to be true' pricing signals

✅

Strong buyer protections in place

30-day seller-paid return policy

Standard secure payments and eBay Money Back Guarantee

Contradictory Signals

The absence of item-level review content slightly weakens direct buyer-level trust, but does not contradict the strong seller reputation.

Signal A: Overall seller feedback is overwhelmingly positive (99.7%) with high sales volume.

Signal B: No detailed user reviews for individual experience with this specific lot.

Category Scores

Identity 97/100

Reputation 95/100

Technical 90/100

Content 90/100

Legal 95/100

Business Validity 95/100

Red Flags & Warnings

The listing does not display explicit user review text or specific product ratings, which can make direct verification of shipped product quality less transparent.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity is consistent and established

Score: 98/100

Passed

"High consistency and longevity, common for professional eBay booksellers."

Reason: The 'Purple Penelope' store is clearly linked to the 'gloriahallelujahllc' eBay username, features a store logo and seller profile, and has 1,600+ live listings.

Reputation score and feedback trends

Score: 95/100

Passed

"No signs of reputation manipulation, feedback flooding, or negative trends."

Reason: The seller holds a 99.7% feedback rating with completed sales numbering over 1,400 for this product and a much larger store volume.

Authenticity and scam reports on web

Score: 85/100

Passed

"Perplexity and forum scans bring back no cautionary stories or regulatory action."

Reason: No scam complaints, counterfeit warnings, or web forum issues found for 'Purple Penelope' or this eBay store.

Listing detail quality and product documentation

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Multiple real photos dispel stock photo concerns for a vintage item. No apparent inconsistencies."

Reason: Photos of the books are clear, multiple, and show actual item condition. Basic condition and attributes are described; product is marked 'pre-owned, acceptable.'

Price and commercial realism

Score: 80/100

Passed

"No pricing anomaly indicating scam, though rare books and vintage lots typically show a range."

Reason: Simak books often list from $20–50 per copy (sometimes far more for signed/first editions). A lot of seven for $39.39 is plausible for normal copies in acceptable condition.

Fulfillment method (shipping, returns, buyer protection)

Score: 95/100

Passed

"Meets or exceeds standard eBay buyer security such as Money Back Guarantee."

Reason: Ships from a declared U.S. location (Georgia). Offers seller-paid 30-day returns and covers return shipping. All payments go via eBay.

Review authenticity

Score: 40/100

Failed

"Not a serious concern with vintage items, but limits product-specific reassurance."

Reason: While overall feedback is excellent, the specific listing displays no actual text reviews for direct validation.

Your Next Steps

1

Review the listing photos carefully to confirm book conditions meet your expectations.
2

Use eBay messaging to ask the seller any specific questions about book editions, printings, or flaws if relevant.
3

Purchase only via eBay’s checkout, avoiding off-site payment offers (which are not present here).
4

Retain transaction records—eBay’s Money Back Guarantee covers purchases in the rare case of issues.

Evidence & Citations

eBay Listing: Vintage A Choice of Gods Mix Lot of 7 Books Softcover by Clifford D. Simak
Listing details, seller info, price, and policies sourced directly from eBay’s product page.
eBay Seller Profile: gloriahallelujahllc (Purple Penelope store)
Store inventory, branding, seller name, and feedback percentage from official eBay storefront.
Online discussions and price checks for Purple Penelope and Simak books
Searches for scam warnings, counterfeit claims, and price comparisons across public and book specialist forums.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →