WebVetted โ„ข Beta
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
Why we think so

This listing offers a new with tags Polo Ralph Lauren leather wallet in black with an all-over Pony print, sold by eBay seller "us-pilci." The item appears to be priced well below Polo Ralph Lauren's official store pricing, with 551 units sold and 23 active watchers. The seller holds a 97.3% positive feedback from buyers, and the listing includes several images showing tags and details. No direct complaints or evidence have been found alleging counterfeit goods or fake reviews linked to the seller. However, eBay's general feedback system can mask negative experiences due to automatic positive comments and return-related removals, making it less reliable as a sole metric. Notably, the seller does not accept returns, which is a caution flag. The price is competitive but not dramatically below market, which reduces the likelihood of the item being a scam, though not eliminating it entirely. If authenticity is critical to you, review the sold feedback linked in the listing and consider verifying the item's photos against official product references or requesting further proof from the seller.

Confidence Score
78%

Risk Insights

๐Ÿ›’

Positive Seller Track Record

Over 550 units sold for this listing
97.3% positive feedback rating
โš ๏ธ

Non-Returnable Item

Seller does not accept returns
Increases risk if item is not as described
๐Ÿ’ฒ

Competitive but Not Suspicious Pricing

Price: $74.99 (official price: $149.99+)
Comparable to other resellers

Contradictory Signals

A reputable reputation is offset by the lack of returns and potential for masked review issues, so due diligence is still necessary.

Signal A: High sales volume and good feedback indicate a legitimate operation.

Signal B: Feedback system limitations and no returns policy increase risk.

Category Scores

Identity 80/100
Reputation 65/100
Technical 75/100
Content 85/100
Legal 80/100
Business Validity 70/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Seller does not accept returns, which makes it harder for buyers to resolve disputes if the item is not as described.
  • eBay feedback can be artificially inflated due to system auto-comments and feedback removal after returns.

๐Ÿ”Ž Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity is traceable and consistent

Score: 80/100
Passed

"Seller identity is consistent with other eBay listings and matches sale history."

Reason: The seller 'us-pilci' has an established eBay presence and a specific feedback profile. Location and buyer history are visible.

Listing content matches claimed product (no misleading details, original photos)

Score: 90/100
Passed

"Listing includes numerous photos showing the wallet and its tags, matching the product name and details."

Reason: Photos, tags, and product condition match official Polo Ralph Lauren styles and descriptions; images look original and unaltered.

Reputation: reviews, feedback, and sales volume indicate legitimate commerce

Score: 70/100
Passed

"Feedback consistency is generally reassuring, but system-generated and potentially removed negatives reduce its trustworthiness."

Reason: The seller has received a high number of positive feedbacks (97.3%) and sold more than 551 units, which typically suggests reliability. However, eBay's review system can inflate positive impressions.

Pricing is in a plausible market range (not extremely low or high)

Score: 70/100
Passed

"The price is competitive but not 'too good to be true', reducing but not eliminating risk."

Reason: At $74.99, the listing is cheaper than buying direct from Polo Ralph Lauren but is not at a suspiciously low price. Comparable resellers list similar products in this range.

Return/refund and shipping policies favor buyer trust and safety

Score: 40/100
Failed

"No returns policy is a notable risk, particularly for branded goods where authenticity may be in question."

Reason: This seller does not accept returns, which limits options if the item is not as described. Most reputable sellers offer at least a basic return window.

No specific external reports, scam alerts, or counterfeit warnings for this seller/listing

Score: 85/100
Passed

"Industry chatter notes platform-wide concerns but doesn't mention 'us-pilci' directly."

Reason: No external sources or community discussions indicate accusations of scamming or selling counterfeit goods by 'us-pilci'.

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    Check the seller's detailed feedback history for recent complaints about item authenticity, quality, or delivery issues.
  • 2
    Compare listing photos with images from the official Polo Ralph Lauren website or reputable retailers to confirm the style and markings.
  • 3
    Contact the seller through eBay to request any additional photos or proof of purchase if you have doubts.
  • 4
    Consider using a payment method with buyer protection (e.g., PayPal, credit card) for increased safety.
  • 5
    If authenticity is essential, opt for sellers who accept returns or provide authenticity guarantees.

Evidence & Citations