WebVetted Beta
Recommendation
Caution
Overall Summary
Suspicious
Why we think so

This eBay listing offers a pre-owned Gucci Sherry Line GG Supreme Leather handbag at just $56—well below the usual resale price of similar models, which often range from about $170 to $999 on reputable platforms like Etsy and Grailed. The seller, yOridOrimidOri, is based in Minato-ku, Japan and has a robust history, boasting over 600 items listed and selling luxury brands such as Louis Vuitton, Tiffany & Co., and Chanel. Nearly 20,000 units have been sold from this account for various items, pointing to a high transaction volume. Despite the extraordinary price, the listing includes a clear description of condition issues and a thorough photo gallery. The seller maintains a 99.4% feedback score and accepts secure payment methods, including PayPal and credit cards, with 30-day free returns. Independent web search found no specific scam alerts or counterfeit complaints about this seller, though potential buyers should remain vigilant given the low price and luxury category. 🛡️

Confidence Score
70%

Risk Insights

⚠️

Unusually Low Price—Stay Alert

Gucci handbag listed for $56—well under the $170–$999 market range.
Low price = higher risk for counterfeits or undisclosed flaws.
Ask for third-party authentication if possible.
🛡️

Strong Seller Track Record on eBay

Over 600 listings and 99.4% positive feedback.
Nearly 20,000 transactions indicate operational history.
No scams reported in independent web search.
🔄

Returns and Payment Safety

30-day free returns offered.
Secure payment (PayPal, credit cards) accepted by seller.
Standard eBay buyer protection applies.

Contradictory Signals

Such a low price from a reputable seller can mean a bargain, but it could also suggest authenticity or condition issues. Proceed with cautious optimism.

Signal A: Seller has a long, positive sales history and high feedback.

Signal B: Product price is far below typical market rates for comparable luxury items.

Category Scores

Identity 80/100
Reputation 75/100
Technical 85/100
Content 65/100
Legal 60/100
Business Validity 50/100

Red Flags & Warnings

  • Extremely low sale price for a pre-owned luxury Gucci handbag compared to similar items.
  • High-volume luxury resellers can sometimes mix authentic and replica items—no proven allegations here, but caution is warranted.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller identity and track record

Score: 80/100
Passed

"Large inventory, positive feedback, and visible sales history indicate seller is established on eBay. No red flags in identity were uncovered."

Reason: Seller operates a large eBay store with at least 616 active listings and nearly 20,000 items sold historically. Feedback score is 99.4%.

Product price consistency and plausibility

Score: 20/100
Failed

"Luxury Gucci bags from this line rarely, if ever, sell below $170 in the second-hand market; $56 is far outside the normal range."

Reason: The $56 price for a listed pre-owned Gucci bag is extremely low compared to typical market value, casting doubt on authenticity or condition.

Listing details (photos, description, transparency)

Score: 75/100
Passed

"The item is described as pre-owned with specific flaws disclosed. Extensive photo documentation supports transparency."

Reason: Listing provides multiple clear photos, a summary of wear and imperfections, and notes on inner damage.

Seller reputation and reviews

Score: 75/100
Passed

"While individual reviews were not detailed, the overall lack of public complaints adds to the seller's reputation."

Reason: Seller maintains a 99.4% positive feedback score over many transactions. No pattern of scam or fake review allegations was found in search.

Returns, shipping, and buyer protection

Score: 85/100
Passed

"Standard eBay buyer protections apply, providing recourse if the item is not authentic or as described."

Reason: 30-day return policy with free return shipping and acceptance of multiple secure payment methods are in place.

External complaints or counterfeit/scam warnings

Score: 70/100
Passed

"Absence of widespread scam claims is reassuring, though the large volume and extremely low price still warrant due diligence."

Reason: No direct scam warnings or counterfeit product complaints about this seller surfaced in independent web search.

Your Next Steps

  • 1
    If you're interested in this bag, request additional photos, especially of the serial number, logo, and receipt/provenance.
  • 2
    Ask if third-party authentication is supported prior to shipment.
  • 3
    Carefully review the seller's detailed feedback for any complaints related to counterfeit items or authenticity questions.
  • 4
    Use eBay's buyer protection and consider only secure payment methods like PayPal.
  • 5
    If authenticity is crucial, consider using a luxury goods authentication service after purchase.

Evidence & Citations