Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

This listing offers a Yamaha Pacifica 611 PG electric guitar pickguard from Feiman Musical Instruments on eBay for $17.50 plus shipping from China. The seller has an established store with 358 items focused mainly on guitar accessories and pickguards, a 97.4% positive feedback, and has sold more than 800 units of this specific item. There are no public scam or counterfeit product reports tied specifically to Feiman Musical Instruments. While general risks exist in the online musical parts niche—such as inconsistent item quality, delayed shipping, or mismatches between photos and the received product—the price, return policy (30 days, buyer pays return), and payment via eBay/paypal all align with legitimate eBay commerce. Prices for similar pickguards from other sellers range from about $10 to $18, so this offer is not unusually low. Always review recent negative feedback for patterns and compare item details and photos to Yamaha specs to rule out generic or ill-fitting parts. Based on all available evidence, this listing appears typical for the category, with no major scam signs present. 🛡️

Confidence Score

85%

Risk Insights

🛡️

No evidence of scam or counterfeit activity

No reports in music gear scams forums or scamwatch sites specifically implicate Feiman Musical Instruments.

97.4% seller feedback and high transaction count confirm typical, non-suspicious eBay activity.

💵

Market pricing and after-sale support

Listing price falls within the normal range for aftermarket pickguards.

30-day return policy and eBay Money Back Guarantee provide additional buyer safety.

Contradictory Signals

While the overall risk of scam is low, buyers should remain alert to possible mismatches in quality or fit common in generic or non-OEM accessories.

Signal A: Seller has high-volume, positive feedback, and no scam reports found.

Signal B: General risk of quality issues and unreliable fulfillment from international aftermarket accessory sellers.

Category Scores

Identity 90/100

Reputation 85/100

Technical 78/100

Content 82/100

Legal 85/100

Business Validity 84/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Seller is located in China, which may result in long shipping times and more difficult returns for international buyers.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller account legitimacy and history

Score: 90/100

Passed

"Longevity, large inventory, and repeat sales indicate a legitimate long-term operation."

Reason: Feiman Musical Instruments has an active eBay store with hundreds of products and years of activity, and maintains a 97.4% positive feedback.

Product listing authenticity and image match

Score: 82/100

Passed

"No obvious image manipulation or unrealistic product appearance was noted. Item listed as aftermarket/replacement part, not misrepresented as official OEM."

Reason: The images are consistent with typical aftermarket pickguards; options and materials stated align with aftermarket accessory norms.

Review and feedback authenticity

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Volume and breadth of feedback suggest natural customer flow, not synthetic or botted reviews."

Reason: Seller feedback above 97% positive, and over 800 sold on this listing. No current patterns of review fraud or repeated negative claims.

Product pricing compared to market

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Fair market price makes scam highly unlikely; no 'too good to be true' risk."

Reason: Competitor pricing for Yamaha Pacifica 611 pickguards range from $10–$18, so the offer is in line with market, not abnormally discounted.

Counterfeit or manipulation indicators

Score: 78/100

Passed

"The main product risk is generic fit/quality, not fraud or counterfeiting."

Reason: No red flags for counterfeiting or manipulation in this listing. As it is an aftermarket part (not represented as Yamaha OEM), originality risk is low if buyer expects a generic part.

Fulfillment patterns and logistics

Score: 75/100

Passed

"Fulfillment arrangement is standard for the Chinese accessories niche; buyer must account for variable shipping times."

Reason: Shipping is from China, so longer transit times are likely but seller provides estimated delivery window and offers returns.

Return, dispute, and buyer protection clarity

Score: 85/100

Passed

"Standard eBay return protocol assures some recourse for non-receipt or not-as-described issues."

Reason: Return window (30 days) and buyer-pays shipping policy are clearly disclosed, and eBay/PayPal protection applies.

Your Next Steps

1

Review negative/neutral Ebay feedback for this seller before purchase to check for unresolved product or shipping issues.
2

Verify returned item conditions and who pays for return shipping in case you have to return the product.
3

Compare the product images and specifications with Yamaha's official documentation to ensure compatibility.
4

Pay only by eBay or PayPal to guarantee buyer protection.

Evidence & Citations

Feiman Musical Instruments eBay store
Store page confirms a large inventory of guitar accessories and established presence.
eBay listing for Yamaha Pacifica 611 Pickguard
Detailed product page for the pickguard with sale history, price and seller information.
Are there reports of scam, counterfeit, or review fraud for Feiman Musical Instruments?
Discussion of general musical gear scams on eBay but no specific mention of Feiman Musical Instruments.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →