Recommendation

Proceed

Overall Summary

Safe

Why we think so

This eBay listing, presented by seller 'allen88_3', offers a range of used PlayStation 4 games for $5 each, located in Liverpool, NSW, Australia. The listing is clear in presenting game choices, condition, and basic seller information. The seller's profile shows a feedback score of 100, and 77 sales for this listing are reported, indicating a moderate level of past transaction activity. There are no clear reports of counterfeit products or fake reviews associated with 'allen88_3' from web searches or in user forums. Still, eBay's feedback system is known to have vulnerabilities like feedback padding and removal of negative reviews, which requires some caution. The description notes potential minor scuffs or sticker residue but says each disc is tested and working. No returns are accepted, and payment options are standard for eBay. While there's no direct evidence of fraud for this seller or listing, buyers should nonetheless examine recent seller feedback and use eBay's buyer protection if issues arise. This listing appears generally legitimate, but keep in mind the limitations of eBay's feedback system. 🕵️

Confidence Score

82%

Risk Insights

🛒

Seller scores and recent sales look genuine

77 completed sales for this PS4 games listing.

Feedback score of 100 is modest but positive.

No complaints of scams/counterfeits linked to this seller.

🤔

eBay feedback may not tell the full story

eBay system allows feedback removal, especially after refunds.

Sometimes sellers use feedback padding to inflate scores.

Check most recent reviews before you buy.

📦

No returns policy—inspect on arrival

No returns accepted for this listing.

eBay Money Back Guarantee covers undelivered or not-as-described items.

Contact eBay promptly if issues occur.

Contradictory Signals

While the feedback is positive, eBay's system can allow sellers to remove negatives or obtain repeated positives, so scores alone aren't ironclad.

Signal A: Feedback score is perfect (100), with moderate amount of sales.

Signal B: eBay feedback can be inflated or negative reviews removed, limiting trust in perfect scores.

Category Scores

Identity 86/100

Reputation 74/100

Technical 92/100

Content 85/100

Legal 76/100

Business Validity 78/100

Red Flags & Warnings

eBay's feedback system can hide negative reviews or allow feedback padding, meaning a perfect score doesn't always guarantee safety.
No returns accepted may limit recourse if you are unsatisfied with the item's condition.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Seller real and registered on eBay

Score: 95/100

Passed

"Seller ID matches across listing and feedback profile. No indications of account hijacking or recent rebranding."

Reason: Seller 'allen88_3' is an active, registered eBay user with a matching profile and active sales history.

Legit product inventory and reasonable sales data

Score: 85/100

Passed

"Available titles are common, not high-risk for counterfeits, and pricing aligns with used market averages."

Reason: The listing shows 77 completed sales, a standard price for used PS4 games, and no inventory anomalies.

Transparent and specific product images & description

Score: 88/100

Passed

"Scuffs and sticker residue disclosed; images are clear and represent a range of game titles."

Reason: Multiple photos and explicit notes about the product condition and imperfections.

Authenticity of reviews and feedback

Score: 77/100

Passed

"No clusters of repeated reviews or obvious manipulation. Feedback can be publically inspected."

Reason: While eBay's system has weaknesses, this seller's feedback is modest and does not show padding or suspicious spikes.

Consistent seller reputation: No scam/counterfeit complaints externally

Score: 80/100

Passed

"No results for this seller in scam warning threads, Reddit, or external trust platforms."

Reason: Web/forum research finds no red flags regarding scams, counterfeit products, or fake feedback for 'allen88_3'.

Returns and fulfillment policy clarity

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Buyers covered by eBay Money Back Guarantee regardless of this seller's stated return policy."

Reason: The listing states 'No returns accepted', which is clear, though not buyer-friendly. Payment options are protected.

Your Next Steps

1

Before purchasing, click through the seller's feedback profile to check for very recent buyer experiences.
2

Once item arrives, inspect each game for described condition. Contact eBay resolution support if you receive a non-working or unexpected game.
3

Because no returns are accepted, confirm you are comfortable with potential minor scuffs or sticker residue as described.
4

Pay using payment methods that provide buyer protection (PayPal, Google Pay, Visa, Mastercard).

Evidence & Citations

eBay Listing for Playstation 4 Video Games (allen88_3)
Listing details confirm location, item photos, seller ID, description, and feedback.
eBay Seller Reputation and Scam Discussion
Explains vulnerabilities in eBay feedback systems; no complaints found for this seller.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🛍️ Vet another Ebay Seller

Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.

2 Common Ebay Scams & How To Avoid Them

Scam types: Investigate eBay electronics listings that never deliver; Spot counterfeit luxury goods online

Read playbook →

Scam Encyclopedia

Browse platform-specific scams / red flags and see real-world encounters curated by our analysts.

Read playbook →