Ebay Due Diligence
Report for Gem Mint Collectibles
Why we think so
This listing offers a 1995 Ken Griffey Jr. Leaf Statistical Standouts #2 /5000 graded PSA 8.5, sold by Gem Mint Collectibles—a recognized eBay seller based in North Carolina. The store handles a sizable selection (122 items) of vintage and modern graded sports cards, many with high-value price tags. Gem Mint Collectibles shows a 100% positive feedback profile and a long history of trading similar collectibles on eBay, which supports its credibility. However, the card is priced significantly higher ($149.95) than market averages for the same card/grade, which usually sells for $79–$94 on established price indexes and online retailers. The store does not offer standard returns, but eBay’s Money Back Guarantee applies if the item arrives not as described or is proven to be a counterfeit. No clear evidence of counterfeit or fraud appears for either this specific card or the seller, though third-party research is recommended for valuable or high-priced vintage cards. 🛡️ Bottom line: This is a legitimate, established business. Pricing is above market. eBay protections apply, but research market prices and PSA certification before committing, especially at this premium.
Risk Insights
Legit and Experienced Seller
Premium Pricing Notice
No Standard Returns, eBay Guarantee Applies
Contradictory Signals
Seller appears trusted, but risk for overpaying is higher and subjective returns are not accepted.
Signal A: Strong legitimacy indicators: positive feedback, years of operation, specialty inventory.
Signal B: No standard returns, higher price than typical market value.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
-
Selling price ($149.95) is significantly higher than established market rates ($79–$94) for this card in the same PSA grade.
-
Seller does not accept standard returns—buyers can only rely on eBay's Money Back Guarantee if an item is not as described or is counterfeit.
🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis
Seller identity and reputation
Seller identity and reputation
"Feedback and store inventory reflect legitimate, long-term operation with a focus on professional-grade, high-value sports cards."
Reason: Gem Mint Collectibles operates an active eBay store with a perfect feedback track record and a long history in the graded sports collectibles niche.
Product authenticity and description accuracy
Product authenticity and description accuracy
"Images and PSA details are appropriate for this class of collectible. Always verify certification number yourself."
Reason: Listing gives a PSA certification number, serial numbering, and authentic images of the card. No red flags for counterfeit in available sources.
Seller reviews and external complaints
Seller reviews and external complaints
"Public search did not surface credible fraud or rip-off reports tied to this username or storefront."
Reason: Reviewer scans and community research show no meaningful negative patterns or scam/counterfeit incidents connected to this seller.
Price fairness and market consistency
Price fairness and market consistency
"Monitor completed listings and direct market indexes before purchasing at a premium."
Reason: The listing is notably above market ($149.95 vs. typical $79–94 market for this card and grade). Buyer should assess if any added value justifies the premium.
Returns, buyer protections, fulfillment
Returns, buyer protections, fulfillment
"Protection is limited to eBay-eligible issues. Standard returns for subjective reasons not accepted."
Reason: No standard returns, but eBay's Money Back Guarantee protects buyers against incorrect descriptions and counterfeit risk.
Inventory, listing consistency, and sales history
Inventory, listing consistency, and sales history
"Product line and sales patterns match expectations for a serious collectible dealer."
Reason: Seller’s inventory consists of similar high-value vintage cards, indicating expertise and consistency. No anomalies in listing volume or content.
Your Next Steps
-
1Always check the PSA certification number (113868927) directly on the PSA site to confirm it's valid and matches the card description/photo.
-
2Set price alerts or compare across completed eBay listings to ensure the current asking price aligns with recent market values.
-
3If you're buying from overseas, confirm estimated shipping times and insurance details.
-
4If the no-returns policy is a concern, stick to eBay payments for Money Back Guarantee coverage.
Evidence & Citations
-
Gem Mint Collectibles eBay Store
Shows the seller's legitimacy, inventory size, and positive feedback.
-
Ken Griffey Jr 1995 Leaf Statistical Standouts #2 /5000 PSA 8.5 eBay Listing
Details the item description, seller information, payment, and shipping policies.
-
Price Comparison and Complaints Research
Aggregates price comparisons and reports no clear evidence of scam or counterfeit linked to this seller.
🕵🏻 Keep investigating
Vet TikTok, eBay, Amazon, or Facebook Marketplace storefronts.
Some shops advertise brand-name goods but ship random factory surplus once they capture payment. ScamAI looks at fulfill...
Read playbook →Fake shops borrow official brand names, then redirect to off-platform checkout links. ScamAI inspects registration docs,...
Read playbook →