Ebay Due Diligence
Report for Aahealth-beauty7171
Why we think so
This eBay listing offers Yves Saint Laurent Rouge Pur Couture Satin Lipstick from seller aahealth-beauty7171, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The item is described as new and comes with a return policy covering 30 days, with free return shipping. The product's listed price ($33) is noticeably lower than the typical retail price for the same lipstick, which is about $45–$48 at major retailers like Sephora and Macy's. Over 1,500 units have reportedly been sold, but only four reviews are immediately visible for this item, and detailed seller reputation metrics are currently unavailable. While the product photos and description appear consistent with legitimate YSL packaging and features, buyers should remain vigilant because the price is significantly lower than standard retail for a new, luxury-brand item. No explicit complaints about counterfeiting or fake reviews were found, but general online advice for buying YSL lipsticks on eBay emphasizes caution. To proceed, thoroughly review seller feedback (if accessible), watch for signs of authenticity in product photos, and consider purchasing only from sellers with a clear and demonstrated record of positive transactions.
Risk Insights
Significant price gap vs. official retail
Few visible reviews for high sale volume
30-day free returns enhance buyer safety
Surface-level authenticity, but risk remains
Contradictory Signals
The listing looks like a genuine YSL product, but price and lack of feedback raise reasonable suspicion.
Signal A: Product photos and features look authentic.
Signal B: Price is far below market and feedback stats are missing.
Category Scores
Red Flags & Warnings
-
Major price difference compared to official and large retailer pricing, which is a common red flag for luxury counterfeit goods.
-
Lack of readily accessible eBay seller reputation and feedback statistics.
🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis
Seller reputation and sales history
Seller reputation and sales history
"While over 1,500 units are marked as sold, only four reviews are visible, raising questions about the authenticity of the transactions, the source, or how feedback is collected on this product."
Reason: No detailed seller reputation or feedback score could be confirmed, and there are very few reviews for this high-volume listing.
Product authenticity indicators in listing
Product authenticity indicators in listing
"Box, shade options, and listed features align with the genuine product. No obvious signs of fake packaging are seen in available photos."
Reason: Product images, variants, and descriptions closely match those from official YSL channels.
Price vs. comparable market value
Price vs. comparable market value
"Legitimate major retailers and YSL's own website list this lipstick for $45–$48. A price far below that, offered as 'new', requires careful scrutiny."
Reason: The listing price is at least $12 below official retail from authorized stores. Significant discounting of new, luxury cosmetic goods is common in listings for counterfeits.
Return policy and buyer protections
Return policy and buyer protections
"A clear return window helps mitigate risks if the product proves inauthentic or unsatisfactory."
Reason: Listing provides a 30-day return policy with prepaid shipping — a positive for buyer safety.
Legal and compliance information
Legal and compliance information
"Listing appears to include all required info for a cosmetic on eBay (ingredients are commonly omitted from such brief listings)."
Reason: No explicit legal red flags (such as prohibited claims, missing disclosures, or absence of key product details).
Potential counterfeit warning signals
Potential counterfeit warning signals
"No outright evidence of fakes or complaints, but combination of listed risk factors justifies caution."
Reason: Price undercut, very limited feedback, and high sales volume are risk signals commonly associated with cosmetics counterfeiting on eBay.
Your Next Steps
-
1Carefully review the seller's detailed feedback and recent transaction history on their profile page before considering purchase.
-
2Examine all product photos to check for authenticity markers (official logos, consistent packaging, batch codes).
-
3If you buy, document the unboxing process and inspect the lipstick for authenticity; refuse and report to eBay if the item is not as described.
-
4Compare the listing details and images to those on official brand or retailer sites, looking for inconsistencies.
-
5Only pay through eBay-approved methods to ensure you're covered by eBay's Buyer Protection program.
-
6Be cautious of deeply discounted luxury goods on eBay, as these are more likely to be counterfeit.
Evidence & Citations
-
Yves Saint Laurent Rouge Pur Couture Lipstick Price Comparison – Sephora, Macy's, YSL Beauty
Standard retail price is $45–$48 for this lipstick at verified sellers.
-
eBay Listing for aahealth-beauty7171 – Product Details
Listing information, history of sold quantity, and product description.
🕵🏻 Keep investigating
Verify if a Ebay seller is safe to buy from: detect counterfeits, fake reviews and red flags.
Counterfeit rings list designer bags and watches using stolen catalog photos. ScamAI reviews serial numbers, past takedo...
Read playbook →Sellers list scarce GPUs or consoles, collect payment, and disappear with tracking numbers that never update. ScamAI ana...
Read playbook →